• Follow us

Social Media

Facebook co-founder, Chris Hughes, calls for Facebook to be broken up – TechCrunch

The latest call to break up Facebook looks to be the most uncomfortably close to home yet for supreme leader, Mark Zuckerberg.

“Mark’s power is unprecedented and un-American,” writes Chris Hughes, in an explosive op-ed published in The New York Times. “It is time to break up Facebook.”

It’s a long read, but worth indulging for a well-articulated argument against the market-denting power of monopolies, shot through with a smattering of personal anecdotes about Hughes’ experience of Zuckerberg — who he at one point almost paints as “only human,” before shoulder-dropping into a straight thumbs-down that “it’s his very humanity that makes his unchecked power so problematic.”

The tl;dr of Hughes’ argument against Facebook/Zuckerberg being allowed to continue its/his reign of the internet knits together different strands of the techlash zeitgeist, linking Zuckerberg’s absolute influence over Facebook, and therefore over the unprecedented billions of people he can reach and behaviourally reprogram via content-sorting algorithms, to the crushing of innovation and startup competition; the crushing of consumer attention, choice and privacy, all hostage to relentless growth targets and an eyeball-demanding ad business model; the crushing control of speech that Zuckerberg — as Facebook’s absolute monarch — personally commands, with Hughes worrying it’s a power too potent for any one human to wield.

“Mark may never have a boss, but he needs to have some check on his power,” he writes. “The American government needs to do two things: break up Facebook’s monopoly and regulate the company to make it more accountable to the American people.”

His proposed solution is not just a break up of Facebook’s monopoly of online attention by re-separating Facebook, Instagram and WhatsApp — to try to reinvigorate a social arena it now inescapably owns — he also calls for U.S. policymakers to step up to the plate and regulate, suggesting an oversight agency is also essential to hold internet companies to account, and pointing to Europe’s recently toughened privacy framework, GDPR, as a start.

“Just breaking up Facebook is not enough. We need a new agency, empowered by Congress to regulate tech companies. Its first mandate should be to protect privacy,” he writes. “A landmark privacy bill in the United States should specify exactly what control Americans have over their digital information, require clearer disclosure to users and provide enough flexibility to the agency to exercise effective oversight over time. The agency should also be charged with guaranteeing basic interoperability across platforms.”

Once an equally fresh-faced co-founder of Facebook alongside his Harvard roommate, Hughes left Facebook in 2007, walking away with what would become eye-watering wealth — writing later that he made half a billion dollars, for three years’ work, off the back of Facebook’s 2012 IPO.

It’s harder to put a value on the relief Hughes must also feel, having exited the scandal-hit behemoth so early on — getting out before early missteps hardened into a cynical parade of privacy, security and trust failures that slowly, gradually yet inexorably snowballed into world-wide scandal — with the 2016 revelations about the extent of Kremlin-backed political disinformation lighting up the dark underbelly of Facebook ads.

Soon after, the Cambridge Analytica data misuse scandal shone an equally dim light into similarly murky events on Facebook’s developer platform — some of which appeared to hit even closer to home. (Facebook had its own staff helping to target those political ads, and hired the co-founder of the company that had silently sucked out user data in order to sell manipulative political propaganda services to Cambridge Analytica.) 

It’s clear now that Facebook’s privacy, security and trust failures are no accident; rather, they are chain-linked to Zuckerberg’s leadership, to his strategy of a never-ending sprint for relentless, bottomless growth — via what was once literally a stated policy of “domination.” 

Hughes, meanwhile, dropped out — coming away from Facebook a very rich man and, if not entirely guilt-free given his own founding role in the saga, certainly lacking Zuckerberg-levels of indelible taint.

Though we can still wonder where his well-articulated concern, about how Facebook’s monopoly grip on markets and attention is massively and horribly denting the human universe, has been channelled prior to publishing this NYT op-ed — i.e. before rising alarm over Facebook’s impact on societies, democracies, human rights and people’s mental health scaled so disfiguringly into mainstream view.

Does he, perhaps, regret not penning a critical op-ed before Roger McNamee, an early Zuckerberg advisor with a far less substantial role in the whole drama, got his 20 cents in earlier this year — publishing a critical book, Zucked, which recounts his experience trying and failing to get Zuckerberg to turn the tanker and chart a less collaterally damaging course.

It’s certainly curious it has taken Hughes so long to come out of the woodwork and join the big techlash.

The NYT review of “Zucked” headlined it as an “anti-Facebook manifesto” — a descriptor that could apply equally to Hughes’ op-ed. And in an interview with TC back in February, McNamee — whose more limited connection to Zuckerberg Facebook has sought to dismiss — said of speaking out: “I may be the wrong messenger, but I don’t see a lot of other volunteers at the moment.”

Facebook certainly won’t be able to be so dismissive of Hughes’ critique, as a fellow co-founder. This is one Zuckerberg gut-punch that will both hurt and be harder to dodge. (We’ve asked Facebook if it has a response and will update if so.)

At the same time, hating on Facebook and Zuckerberg is almost fashionable these days — as the company’s consumer- and market-bending power has flipped its fortunes from winning friends and influencing people to turning frenemies into out-and-out haters and politically charged enemies.

Indeed, it’s former mentors, former colleagues, and now, of course, politicians and policymakers leading the charge and calling for the company to be broken up.

Seen from that angle, it’s a shame Hughes waited so long to add his two cents. It does risk him being labelled an opportunist — or, dare we say it, a techlash populist. (Some of us have been banging on about Facebook’s intrusive influence for years, so, er, welcome to the club Chris!) 

Though, equally, he may have been trying to protect his historical friendship with Zuckerberg. (The op-ed begins with Hughes talking about the last time he saw Zuckerberg, in summer 2017, which it’s hard not to read as him tacitly acknowledging there likely won’t be any more personal visits after this bombshell.)

Hughes is also not alone in feeling he needs to bide his time to come out against Zuckerberg.

The WhatsApp founders, who jumped the Facebook mothership last year, kept their heads down and their mouths shut for years, despite a product philosophy that boiled down to “fuck ads” — only finally making their lack of love for their former employer’s ad-fuelled privacy incursions into WhatsApp clear post-exit from the belly of the beast — in their own subtle and not so subtle ways.

In their case they appear to have been mostly waiting for enough shares to vest. (Brian Acton did leave a bunch on the table.) But Hughes has been sitting on his money mountain for years.

Still, at least we finally have his critical — and rarer — account to add to the pile; a Facebook co-founder, who had remained close to Zuckerberg’s orbit, finally reaching for the unfriend button.

Update: In a response statement attributed to its VP of global affairs and communications, Nick Clegg, Facebook said:

Facebook accepts that with success comes accountability. But you don’t enforce accountability by calling for the breakup of a successful American company. Accountability of tech companies can only be achieved through the painstaking introduction of new rules for the internet. That is exactly what Mark Zuckerberg has called for. Indeed, he is meeting Government leaders this week to further that work.

Read More



Leave A Comment

More News

TechCrunch » Social

Maisie Williams’ talent discovery startup Daisie raises $2.5 2019-05-20 16:17:57Maisie Williams’ time on Game of Thrones may have come to an end, but her talent discovery app Daisie is just getting started. Co-founded by fil

Why is Facebook doing robotics research? 2019-05-20 16:06:41It's a bit strange to hear that the world's leading social network is pursuing research in robotics rather than, say, making search useful, but Face

Instagram’s IGTV copies TikTok’s AI, Snapchat’s design 2019-05-20 15:49:40Instagram conquered Stories, but it’s losing the battle for the next video formats. TikTok is blowing up with an algorithmically suggested verti

On the Internet of Women with Moira Weigel 2019-05-20 12:15:26“Feminism,” the writer and editor Marie Shear famously said in an often-misattributed quote, “is the radical notion that women are p

TikTok owner ByteDance’s long-awaited chat app is here 2019-05-19 22:49:55In WeChat -dominated China, there’s no shortage of challengers out there claiming to create an alternative social experience. The latest creatio

Facebook changes algorithm to promote worthwhile & close 2019-05-16 11:14:04Facebook is updating the News Feed ranking algorithm to incorporate data from surveys about who you say are your closest friends and which links you f

Instagram adds Stories to Explore tab. Here’s how 2019-05-16 09:59:47Instagram’s pivot to Stories continues with an overhaul of Explore designed to let users dig deeper into their niche interests. Stories are now

Instagram is killing Direct, its standalone Snapchat clone 2019-05-16 07:09:53As Facebook pushes ahead with its strategy to consolidate more of the backend of its various apps on to a single platform, it’s also doing a lit

Facebook introduces ‘one strike’ policy to combat abuse 2019-05-15 02:09:27Facebook is cracking down on its live-streaming service after it was used to broadcast the shocking mass shootings that left 50 dead at two Christchur

Twitter launches new search features to stop the 2019-05-14 23:05:26As measles outbreaks in the United States and other countries continue to get worse, Twitter is introducing new search tools meant to help users find

Uber Black launches Quiet Driver Mode 2019-05-14 20:02:46Tired of chatty drivers? Uber is finally giving users its most requested feature: an in-app way to ask for minimal conversation during your ride. The

After year-long lockout, Twitter is finally giving people 2019-05-14 14:29:38Twitter is finally allowing a number of locked users to regain control of their accounts once again. Around a  year after Europe’s new priv

Mashable

In the end, the Azor Ahai prophecy did New! 2019-05-21 07:00:00One of the biggest twists of Season 8 is that one of the most oft-debated prophecies, Azor Ahai, a.k.a. the Prince Who Was Promised, seemingly turned

The best and worst merch from the 2020 New! 2019-05-21 07:00:00In case you haven't heard, a bunch of people are running for president. There are already more than 20 candidates campaigning for the 2020 election,

11 essential VR apps every Oculus Quest owner New! 2019-05-21 07:00:00So you've just bought yourself an Oculus Quest. Hello, wireless VR with head and hand-tracking!  You're probably going to download a bunch of g

Chevy cars won't let teen drivers start driving New! 2019-05-21 06:00:00Buckle up. That's not just a suggestion when it comes to new Chevy Traverse, Malibu, and Colorado models arriving this summer.  For teenage driv

The badass book inspiration for Arya's final journey New! 2019-05-21 06:00:00What's west of Westeros? It's the question that Arya Stark sets sail to answer in the Season 8 finale, to discover what lies beyond the edge of the

Your packages could be delivered from a self-driving New! 2019-05-21 06:00:00For the next two weeks, package deliveries in the Southwest could get to your doorstep by way of robo-truck. Starting Tuesday, self-driving truck comp

Jimmy Fallon rips into 'Game of Thrones' for New! 2019-05-21 05:48:19 Uh oh. Looks like someone left a water bottle under their chair in the Game of Thrones finale.  Jimmy Fallon shared his thoughts on the finale

Stephen Colbert imagines the NSFW entry Brienne could New! 2019-05-21 05:20:39 This post contains spoilers, spoilers, and more spoilers. Get away! Brienne of Tarth put pen to paper in the final ever episode of Game of Thrones

Netgear routers, Logitech mouse, Acer monitors, Nintendo Switch, New! 2019-05-21 05:11:24With Father's Day creeping up, don't be that person that buys a gift last minute and pay more than you have to. Today, Amazon is offering up to 50%

6 emergency tools on sale for less than New! 2019-05-21 05:00:00Accidents happen, things break, and climate change means that extreme weather has now become the norm. Point is: it’s always good to be prepared

Save 96% off this massive project management training New! 2019-05-21 05:00:00Being a project manager admittedly doesn't sound super "cool." A kindergartner likely wouldn't say they want to be a project manager when they gro

7 loose ends still bothering us from that New! 2019-05-21 05:00:00Game of Thrones came to an end on Sunday, but we still have plenty of burning questions. From plot holes to cliff hangers, the loose ends left in West

The Next Web

CHEAP: Binge into oblivion with $1,000 off an New! 2019-05-21 08:15:37Game of Thrones just ended this week, but that doesn’t mean your (TV) watch should end. And if you’re looking for a swanky 4K smart TV, we

These $300 Bang & Olafsen headphones are only New! 2019-05-21 08:00:00If you’ve never tried any B&O tech before, you can find out what the excitement is about with a set of their Beoplay H4 Wireless Headphones.

Boring but necessary: 4 budgeting mistakes to avoid New! 2019-05-21 07:42:15It may sound boring, but careful and sensible budgeting is crucial to every growing company. Not only does successful budgeting save time and energy,

Australian civil servant faces 10 years for mining New! 2019-05-21 06:27:38An Australian government employee is appearing in court today after using work equipment to mine cryptocurrency for his own gain. The Australian Feder

How an engineer at a crypto-security startup lost New! 2019-05-21 06:23:41Nobody is immune to SIM-swapping attacks – and one engineering lead at a cryptocurrency security startup had to learn this lesson the hard way.

Bitcoin ETFs still a mirage as SEC delays New! 2019-05-21 05:21:07The US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) is still not keen on approving Bitcoin exchange-traded funds (ETF). In a document published on May 20,

Bullish Brits lost $34M to cryptocurrency scams last New! 2019-05-21 05:11:03British investors lost £27 million ($34.38 million) to cryptocurrency scams over the last financial year, according to one of the UK’

You can now try out Microsoft’s Edge browser New! 2019-05-21 04:03:34Microsoft has officially announced a preview of its Microsoft Edge browser for the macOS. Microsoft originally unveiled plans for the browser at its a

Private data (including rates) of 49M Instagram influencers New! 2019-05-21 04:00:41Last night, TechCrunch reported that a massive database containing info of over 49 million Instagram influencers, celebrities, and brand accounts foun

Trump delays Huawei ban by 90 days New! 2019-05-21 03:22:04After a horrid 24 hours, there’s finally some respite for Huawei. The US Commerce Department has given the company a 90-day exten

Research indicates the only defense against killer AI 2019-05-20 17:16:17A recent analysis on the future of warfare indicates that countries that continue to develop AI for military use risk losing control of the battlefiel

Sony blindsides PS5 team with news of Microsoft 2019-05-20 16:39:09The team-up announced last week between gaming’s eternal blood rivals, Microsoft and Sony, came as a surprise to many — including, apparen

E-Commerce Times

What Happens to Sprint if T-Mobile Merger Fails? 2019-05-09 14:39:27Sprint's best shot at success is to merge with T-Mobile. Without the merger, I see the company continuing to struggle as a weak player in the competi

The Vital Role of Customer Service in the 2019-05-08 14:50:35By 2022, the sharing economy is expected to double, reaching $40 Billion. Pioneers such as Airbnb and Uber are now global titans, taking in billions o

Amazon Touts Small Biz Success on Its Platform 2019-05-08 13:24:56Third-party gross physical merchandise sales on Amazon, made primarily by SMBs, accounted for more than half the units sold in the company's stores a

Einstein Analytics for Financial Services 2019-05-07 14:51:40It's not that Salesforce has introduced more artificial intelligence apps for its Einstein analytics tool set -- this time for financial services --

Spring Cleaning Your Network Security 2019-05-07 13:27:44Spring may be my favorite time of year. The snow is melting, the sun is shining, and the air smells just a little bit fresher. It's as though the wor

4 Advanced Ways Brands Use Data to Increase 2019-05-06 15:18:39Data is one of the biggest advantages e-commerce brands have over their brick-and-mortar counterparts. Brands that sell products online can glean insi

Small Biz Reaps Major Benefits With Oracle Autonomous 2019-05-04 08:00:00Drop Tank is a small company in footprint -- it started with only 22 people -- but it has an outsized mission: to provide loyalty and discount program

What Everyone's Getting Wrong About Digital Transformation 2019-05-03 14:57:40Digital transformation is all the rage right now, and tech companies are working hard to promote it. You can hardly take an action online or go to a c

The Critical Role of Artificial Intelligence in Payments 2019-05-02 15:05:07Long an obsession of science fiction writers, "artificial intelligence" in the modern era of fast-paced technological innovation is a term that is a

AI Raises the Bar for Home Network Security 2019-05-02 13:25:59Consumers are becoming increasingly concerned about the hacking of their devices and data as they hear about more data breaches and have their own exp

New CRM Research Shows Awareness Gap 2019-05-01 16:07:33CRM guru Esteban Kolsky and I did some primary research earlier this year, paid for by Zoho. We wanted to improve our understanding of what buyers of

Facebook's Ad Library API Draws Fire 2019-05-01 13:21:16Facebook has come under fire for its Ad Library API, which lets users perform customized keyword searches of all active and inactive ads related to po


Disclaimer and Notice:WorldProNews.com is not responsible of these news or any information published on this website.