• Follow us


The Democratic Debate That Wasn't: How Tech Could Help Elections | Tech Buzz

I watched the Democratic debates last week and was struck by three things: I'd likely rather watch paint dry; the application of technology to improve the experience was nonexistent; and I'd bet that if the Democrats don't up their game President Trump will have them to thank when he wins re-election.

I'm generally frustrated about how little technology is used to improve the presentations made by technology companies, but in this case both the preservation of the U.S. and perhaps the survival of the world are tied to the next election, and last week's effort fell well below what should have been done.

I'll suggest some ways technology could be used to improve events like the non-debate the Democrats put on last week. I'll close with my product of the week: Amazon's new Echo Show 5, which has taken the lead for price performance among digital assistants.

How to Improve Political Debates

Given how much the Democrats complain about the U.S. president's inability to tell the truth, you'd think that if they put on something called a "debate" it would include some debating. The closest we got to that last week was when the folks on stage went off script and started yelling at each other. (That was more argument than debate but at least it was interesting.)

We used to have to watch things like this live, and there were time limits that created ugly compromises, much like we saw last week. No one got enough time. However, we are at critical mass for people who stream content now. Plus, our TVs are increasingly intelligent, and most of us have some digital device with us as we watch a debate.

This means debates could be more dynamic. For those who don't know a candidate, provide links so they can learn more without having to go off on their own and search Google (which happened a lot).

In addition, with an app you could allow viewers to stream a full argument from a politician they were interested in and get the complete picture of a position. You then could, through automatic transcription and the application of an AI, get near real-time comparisons between a number of politicians at once, so you could identify those you mostly agreed with and separate from those you thought were nuts. Granted, this doesn't help if they are all nuts.

You must believe that the political parties, not to mention the social networks, know all about you, and they could point out which candidates are the most aligned to your mindset and interests. I know a few years back when we had no incumbent, a similar analysis (I'm a Republican) indicated my views were closest to moderate Democrat Joe Biden.

With smart glasses, or simply a feed to their podiums, candidates could get real-time updates and help from their staff. Once they had the job, they would have the CIA, FBI, NSA, Secret Service, State Department and other organizations to rely on. They wouldn't need to rely on their memories alone, and they shouldn't be in the habit of doing that.

Many of our problems are the result of politicians unnecessarily firing from the hip because they failed to research their positions or to use their resources in a timely way. In a data-rich age, we should have fewer hip shooters, not more.

Demonstrating the capability to use technology in real time to improve positions and decisions should be a requirement of the job, and it isn't cheating in this instance. These people aren't competing in a game show -- they are trying to showcase that they would be the best candidate. The job will require them to use the vast resources of the U.S. -- not act like some old guy who only watches Fox News and chases kids off his lawn in his substantial free time.

There was a lot of wasted screen space during the debate, which could have been used to provide background on the candidates or display information about what people are searching on most frequently. Granted, you'd want to use a censoring AI to make sure folks didn't game that system to prank the speakers or do them harm. Just a running chart on what folks were searching on would tell the viewer, moderators and even speakers what was resonating so they could appeal to the audience more effectively.

Why is it necessary to have an audience in the room? That just forces a rigid timeline, and that timeline reduces understanding as well as the effectiveness and entertainment value of the result. Yes, an audience provides applause, but that tends to slow down the process anyway.

Now of the 10 people on the stage, chances are you are only interested in two or three of them. An AI could help you pick which two or three (and make recommendations for those who aren't on your list). Then it also could formulate and present a virtual debate surrounding issues you care about between the two candidates using an AI clone.

Recall that IBM Watson did a really good job of debating a real debate champion a few months ago. It lost, but it showcased that you could program an AI to perform as a debater. If you trained multiple AIs on the politicians, users could pick those they wanted and pit them against each other virtually. Granted, each campaign would need to train its own AI, but the AI also could answer questions from voters at scale.

Now we also can engage at scale through smartphone apps or websites. Moderators have choices of questions, and they could have the audience vote on the questions to ask and even which candidates to ask them of in real time. That way the event automatically would be optimized for the people who tuned in.

Tracking Things Like Equal Time

Coverage of the candidates went from around 10 minutes, which wasn't enough, to five minutes, which was a joke. I mean, why show up if you are only going to get five minutes out of two hours? Moderators can get running tallies that showcase who is getting the least coverage and then could direct more questions to those people.

Given what happened between Bernie Sanders and Hillary Clinton in the last election, special care should be taken at least to appear fairer so large numbers of voters wouldn't feel disenfranchised again and stay home.

Real-Time Translation

It was cute to see some of the politicians speak Spanish, but there is a decent chance that most of their audience wasn't that impressed, because they didn't. We could do real-time translation, though, and either pop up subtitles or have a voiceover with the translation.

The politicians wouldn't have to repeat themselves, and viewers could hear or see the response in their preferred language. I think language skills are a plus in a politician, particularly when it comes to negotiations, and this would allow a politician to show off those skills without pissing off or losing the audience.

Job Interview at Scale

When you and I interview for a job we start with a resume and then sit for an interview focused on whether we have the skills for the job. We don't get on TV and get asked a bunch of wide-ranging questions, have little or no time to answer them, and then get sniped at by our competitors.

The interview process may have very little to do with the job we will get, but this fake debate format is even further from the job a president will do. In short, all these folks are attempting to showcase skills they may never use outside of the campaign.

A real debate would be closer to a negotiation they might have to do between countries, but wouldn't it be nice to hear some details from folks who worked with them on how well they did their past jobs?

Having a job and doing that job well are potentially two different things, and rather than just focusing on questions having to do with the next job, wouldn't it make more sense to focus on how well they did in the last one?

If it really isn't going to be a debate, why not just make this a job interview? You could show some of the questions in real time but provide links to more extensive interviews for audience members who might want to drill down.

I'm suggesting that with technology we could focus a bit more on competence and a ton less on BS. Maybe, just maybe, we'd get a final choice for president of both candidates being qualified rather than the more typical case of neither making the grade.

Wrapping Up

We have all this technology, and the information out there on each one of us could fill books, but it's not being used to improve our election process, in terms of fielding the best candidates for the job. Technology not only could make election events more interesting, but also could help us make better choices between candidates, and perhaps get us back to talking about issues rather than the latest ad hominem attack.

Whether in politics or in technology, the goal appears to be to just to get through the event when it should be to help us make better, more informed choices. Borrowing from The Six Million Dollar Man, we have the technology -- why don't we fricken use it to improve our world, starting with helping us make better political choices? Maybe, in the future, our governments would get the things done we want done. Right now, I doubt our government even knows what that is.

Rob Enderle's Product of the Week

I was one of the early adopters for the Amazon Echo Show and it had some issues -- from a camera that made it iffy in the bedroom to a price that pushed it out of range for most of us.

Then came the Echo Spot, which was far more attractively priced but had a tiny display that was almost useless, along with a camera. Both had buttons to turn the cameras off, but it was easy to turn them back on again without the user knowing, which is problematic when it comes to privacy expectations and some laws.

Amazon Show 5

Amazon Show 5

Well the new Echo Show is priced like the Spot was (around US$89), has a larger and more useful display, plus a slider that physically blocks the camera and puts a white dot on the face to show you the camera has been blocked. Someone would have to come into the room to turn the camera on, and doing so would remove the white dot. (I'd still like a bigger alert that the camera is active myself, but this is an improvement.)

There still is a larger Echo Show for $229 with twice the screen and better speakers, but you can upgrade this Show with Bluetooth speakers for better sound, and the 5-inch display is fine for most things. (You aren't watching movies on a 10-inch device anyway). The larger one also has a Zigbee smart hub that most will never use.

This is likely the perfect Echo device for many, in that it is well-priced, has the full feature set (including video), and is useful in most of the places you'd use it. I'd still like more choices as to activation words, as every one of the Echos I have has a different word, and everyone fires up unintentionally from time to time. (My favorite is watching Star Trek and having the one in my living room, which answers to "computer," try to respond to the TV actors interacting with the computer in the Enterprise or Discovery).

I also anticipate a future app for the Echo Show 5 that would call out BS every time someone on the TV lied. Granted, when some politicians are talking, it might have a meltdown. Still, because this is the best Echo to date and I am up to my armpits in Echo devices, the new Amazon Echo Show is my product of the week.

During the coming Amazon Prime day, I'll bet you can buy one of these for closer to $50, which would be a huge deal. Christmas shopping early, anyone?

The opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of ECT News Network.

Rob Enderle has been an ECT News Network columnist since 2003. His areas of interest include AI, autonomous driving, drones, personal technology, emerging technology, regulation, litigation, M&E, and technology in politics. He has an MBA in human resources, marketing and computer science. He is also a certified management accountant. Enderle currently is president and principal analyst of the Enderle Group, a consultancy that serves the technology industry. He formerly served as a senior research fellow at Giga Information Group and Forrester. Email Rob.

Read More

Leave A Comment

More News


Clean Energy Solutions to Lower Your Electric Bill 2019-07-01 14:47:21Utility bills can get astronomical in the summer and winter. You can reduce those costs and your carbon footprint by signing up for Arcadia Power. Acc

The Democratic Debate That Wasn't: How Tech Could 2019-07-01 08:43:36I watched the Democratic debates last week and was struck by three things: I'd likely rather watch paint dry; the application of technology to improv

NSA Admits Improper Collection of Phone Data, 2nd 2019-06-27 05:39:54The ACLU has released documents showing the NSA improperly collected Americans' call and text logs in November 2017 and in February and October 2018.

Chinese Hackers Linked to Global Attacks on Telcos 2019-06-26 13:04:05Chinese hackers likely are responsible for a series of cyberattacks against telecommunications companies around the world, security researchers have r

Next-Gen Raspberry Pi 4 Packs Power Plus Potential 2019-06-25 13:59:05The next big Raspberry Pi thing is now here, with lots more computing power and more options. The Raspberry Pi Foundation has announced the availabili

Proposed Law Would Force Big Tech to Reveal 2019-06-25 06:15:22A Democrat and a Republican have filed a U.S. Senate bill to require companies to report to financial regulators and to the public what consumer data

6 Things We Won't Be Able to Live 2019-06-24 14:53:38Things rarely happen as fast as we think or progress as slowly as we hope. We all thought we'd have flying cars by the end of last century, for insta

Uber Drones to Make Meal Drops This Summer 2019-06-21 05:57:31Uber Elevate, the aerial arm of rideshare service Uber, will test a fast food delivery by drone service later this summer in San Diego. Delivery dest

Firefox Users Warned to Patch Critical Flaw 2019-06-20 06:23:16Firefox users should update their browsers immediately to fix a critical zero-day vulnerability. Anyone using Firefox on a Windows, macOS or Linux des

In Zuck We Trust: Facebook to Launch Own 2019-06-19 13:37:13Facebook's plans to mint its own digital coin will test the company's consumer credibility. After being savaged for months for its cavalier attitude

Instagram Targets Account Hijacking 2019-06-18 13:42:04Account hijacking has become a nettlesome problem at Instagram so it has decided to do something about it. The social media company has begun testing

Improving Digital Literacy in the Workplace 2019-06-17 18:50:57It's anticipated that in the next five years 90 percent of the workforce will require at least basic computer skills, such as using email or company


Nvidia's GeForce RTX 'Super' cards aim to one-up 2019-07-02 09:00:00Nvidia promised something Super is coming well over a month ago, and on Tuesday, the wait paid off. The graphics company unveiled not one, not two, bu

Nvidia GeForce RTX 2060 Super and RTX 2070 2019-07-02 09:00:00Nvidia promised something Super is coming well over a month ago, and on Tuesday, it finally delivered. Spoiler alert: The wait was worth it.The $399 G

Best robot vacuums: We name the most effective 2019-07-02 06:00:00Vacuuming is one of the most hated household chores. Here are your best choices for outsourcing it to some automated help.

Ecovacs Deebot 500 review: This budget-priced household helper 2019-07-02 06:00:00With app control plus Amazon Alexa and Google Assistant support, this robot vacuum packs a punch for the price.

The five devices you need to work anytime 2019-07-01 23:00:00The modern workplace is more flexible than ever before. This is mainly thanks to high-speed internet connections and the huge advancements in mobile t

Four reasons to buy an Always-Connected PC 2019-07-01 23:00:00 Laptops have always been a perfect blend of portability and power, making them the ideal solution for working whether you’re at home, in the of

Microsoft's fall release of Windows 10 will be 2019-07-01 18:25:00If you’ve been wondering what Microsoft’s next feature release of Windows 10—19H2—has in store, the answer is: not much.Micros

Tobii lands former Intel PC chip VP to 2019-07-01 17:51:00Eye-tracking tech provider Tobii said Monday that it has named Anand Srivatsa, the former vice president of Intel’s Client Computing Group, as T

Best power banks of 2019: The top USB 2019-07-01 13:24:00Anyone who uses a smartphone knows the importance of carrying a backup power bank. But given the large number of options on Amazon, you might feel ove

Best cheap laptops: We rate the best-sellers on 2019-07-01 10:05:00When you’re looking for a good, cheap laptop, knowledge is power. Every budget machine (which we’re defining as Windows laptops costing $5

OmniCharge Omni 20+ Power Bank review: A one-stop 2019-07-01 06:30:00The OmniCharge Omni 20+ is a successful follow up to the Omni 20, simply because OmniCharge no longer has different models of the same charger with di

Bose Home Speaker 300 review: A versatile smart 2019-07-01 06:00:00The newest (and smallest) addition to Bose’s smart speaker line sounds sweet, speaks both Amazon Alexa and Google Assistant, and encourages the

FOX News

Germany fines Facebook $2.3 million for violating hate 2019-07-02 12:56:36Germany hit Facebook with a fine for a lack of transparency in how it handles and reports hate speech complaints.

Facebook buildings evacuated after mail tests positive for 2019-07-01 16:47:27Four buildings that receive and mail for social media giant Facebook were evacuated Monday after a bag of mail tested positive for the nerve

Soldiers use AI to fire precision grenades, guide 2019-07-01 15:50:32The Pentagon’s research and technology arm is testing a “breakthrough” AI-enabled technology for dismounted mobile combat units that

Tiny robots are ‘dominating space’ 2019-07-01 15:30:19China calls them scavengers, Russia calls them inspectors and the US calls them threats.

Civil rights activists slam Facebook's 'insufficient' attempts to 2019-07-01 12:48:20Facebook's latest update on its ongoing companywide civil rights audit has been criticized by activists who say that the social network needs to do m

Facebook cryptocurrency, life-saving smartphones and more: Tech Q&A 2019-06-30 07:00:55Please help me solve a debate. I say my smart TV can get bit by malware and viruses. My buddy says I am a dope. Who’s right? A six-pack is ridin

4 chilling lessons from a tech hotline scam 2019-06-29 07:00:32Some people think they’re immune to cybercriminals. “I’m not even on their radar,” they think. “What are the chances tha

Seedy app that 'undressed' women sparks backlash, taken 2019-06-28 15:36:41A seedy app that used a type of artificial intelligence to “undress” images of clothed women has been taken offline by its developers.

Apple moves production of $6G Mac Pro to 2019-06-28 09:50:19Apple is manufacturing its new Mac Pro computer in China, according to people familiar with its plans, shifting abroad production of what had bee

Google Maps can now tell you how bad 2019-06-28 09:35:00Three weeks after Google announced Google Maps updates to help you stay safe in the event of a natural disaster, the company detailed a solution for a

Apple wants to make Oscar-worthy movies to beef 2019-06-17 12:50:56Apple has Oscar envy.

Google wants next billion users, but has no 2019-06-17 11:09:24Google CEO Sundar Pichai said his company doesn't have plans to launch in China, but that doesn't mean the tech giant wants to ignore its hundreds o


Superhuman removes email location logging, will turn read 2019-07-03 18:40:41Superhuman, the buzzy and currently invite-only email startup that you might have come across even if you yourself don’t have access if you&rsqu

Pod Foods gets VC backing to reinvent grocery 2019-07-03 17:51:22How a failed cookie startup paved the way for next-gen logistics and distribution software.

Lotus’ first electric hypercar finally has a name 2019-07-03 17:48:48The Goodwood Festival of Speed is shaping up to be a big moment for Lotus. The company is finally taking “some” of the wraps off of its fi

Earios is a new podcast network for women 2019-07-03 17:30:59It might seem like you’ve now got podcasts covering any and every conceivable topic, but comedy writer and actor Maria Blascucci argued that the

With Super Mario Maker 2, Nintendo both unleashes 2019-07-03 17:01:03Nintendo's Mario Maker series is among the most generous gifts the company could have given to its fans, and the new installment on Switch is better

Bird investor Upfront Ventures eyes $250M growth fund 2019-07-03 16:03:05The LA-based VC closed on $400 million for its latest early-stage fund in 2017.

Appeals court rules Amazon can be held liable 2019-07-03 15:57:41In a blow to Amazon, a U.S. appeals court ruled that the mega-retailer can be held accountable for faulty third-party sales. The ruling arrived this w

We still don’t know how much of Libra 2019-07-03 15:29:54The $10 million entry fee to join the Facebook-developed cryptocurrency’s Libra Association is merely a minimum. Members who’ll verify tra

GPS on the Moon? NASA’s working on it 2019-07-03 15:23:06If you're driving your car from Portland to Merced, you probably rely on GPS to see where you are. But what if you're driving your Moon rover from O

Pax Labs CEO Bharat Vasan and serial founder 2019-07-03 15:12:30The legalization of cannabis and hemp for medicinal and recreational use in states across the U.S. and in Canada has opened up a huge vein of green, g

Bored before the holiday? Go play the game 2019-07-03 15:11:44The concept of a Google Doodle — the little widget that sometimes replaces the Google logo on the company’s main search page — has g

Daily Crunch: FaceTime gets an eye contact upgrade 2019-07-03 14:09:24The Daily Crunch is TechCrunch’s roundup of our biggest and most important stories. If you’d like to get this delivered to your inbox ever


Jeda launches new Tesla Model 3 USB hub 2019-07-03 18:25:57 Tesla is starting to have a lot of different features utilizing the USB ports in its center console, like Sentry Mode and phone charging, and it can

Podcast: Tesla’s incredible delivery numbers, TSLA departures, Model 2019-07-03 15:47:02 This week on a special holiday weekend Wednesday Electrek Podcast, we discuss the most popular news in the world of sustainable transport and energy,

Tesla is going to allow solar roof and 2019-07-03 14:38:31 Tesla is going to enable homeowners with Tesla solar roof tiles and solar panels to access and dive deep into their own power generation data. more&h

Milwaukee’s Electric String Trimmer is $199 (33% off), 2019-07-03 13:31:00 Today only, Home Depot offers the Milwaukee M18 FUEL 18V Cordless Electric String Trimmer for $199. That’s a $100 savings from the regular

Tesla Pickup truck overtakes Ford F150 as most 2019-07-03 12:59:19 Tesla is good at creating hype without advertising and the Tesla Pickup truck is no exception as it overtakes the Ford F150 as the most talked about

Recent Rivian hires come from Tesla, McLaren, Ford 2019-07-03 12:42:04 Rivian has grown to employ 750 people, with a new report detailing the startup’s recent hires from Tesla, Ford, and McLaren — but most no

Waymo gains approval for transporting passengers in self-driving 2019-07-03 10:51:54 As Waymo continues its push for a driverless future, the Alphabet company is trying to expand to more regions. This week, the state of California has

How climate change deniers inserted themselves into the 2019-07-03 10:35:13 In the ongoing saga of the Trump administration’s efforts to roll back fuel economy standards, it’s been known that automakers sought to

EGEB: A Michigan ‘smart energy district,’ coal country 2019-07-03 09:02:40 In today’s EGEB: Jackson, Michigan is creating a “smart energy district” for energy innovation and testing. Sky-high energy bills i

VW unveils beautiful Type 2 electric conversion microbus 2019-07-03 08:58:59 Volkswagen (VW) has unveiled an electric conversion concept for its iconic Type 2 microbus to celebrate 20 years at its Electronics Research Laborato

Brose unveils all new whisper-quiet electric bicycle drive 2019-07-03 08:31:11 Brose just unveiled its newest electric bicycle drive system. While the company is best known for its ultra quiet mid-drive motor systems, Brose has

Tesla Model 3 aces crash test, sets ‘new 2019-07-03 04:00:43 The European New Car Assessment Programme (Euro NCAP) has released safety and crash test results for new vehicles, including the Tesla Model 3, which

Disclaimer and Notice:WorldProNews.com is not responsible of these news or any information published on this website.