• Follow us

Automotive

My Wild Ride in a Robot Race Car

“Is this the panic button?” I ask, staring at a cartoonishly large red plunger installed on the center console of a Lexus CT 200h.

“Actually yes,” replies Bryan Galusha, cofounder and safety driver from Point One Navigation, a precision location startup that sells souped up GPS rigs to autonomous-vehicle companies. The button disconnects the self-driving system and restores the vehicle to human control.

It’s a cloudy spring day, and we’re in the pit area at Thunderhill West Raceway in Willows, California, where, for the fourth year running, self-driving-car companies are gathering to test out their wares on a closed racecourse. The event is organized by Joshua Schachter, founder of early social-bookmarking service Del.icio.us and also of MemePool, a noted compendium of early internet weirdness. Now he mostly invests in early-stage companies, including many of the outfits at the track today. The event is meant to be a fun meetup of nerdy solidarity, rather than an official proving ground, but the winner will certainly take home bragging rights.

Joshua Schachter invests in early-stage companies and organized the gathering of self-driving-tech companies at hobbyists at the Thunderhill Raceway this spring.

David Robert Elliott

Aaron Nathan, the CEO of Point One, is sitting in the back seat of the Lexus, cradling his laptop. Peering at a column of text on the left of the screen (the rightmost column has what appears to be C++ code), he makes a small change, saves it, and says, “Let’s go!”

Galusha guides us through the first few turns while running down the checklist taped to the steering wheel with Nathan. Before they switch to self-driving mode they make sure every system is on and functioning, almost like a pilot preparing for takeoff. Load route: check! Load mission: check! Verify heading is valid: check!

List done, Galusha takes his hands off the wheel, and it starts moving itself. There is something almost supernatural about this moment that requires a leap of faith, but soon the car is zooming down the track, guided down to 0.1-meter accuracy (hence the company’s name).

In track racing, there’s a concept known as the line: the theoretical perfect path around the course that minimizes total distance, maximizes speed on turns, and involves just brushing the car’s tires against the edge of the inside curve (the so-called apex). An optimal path somewhat resembles a pinball flying through a narrow track and hitting every apex of every inside corner along the way.

Earlier, alongside the Point One pit crew, we had watched on a map as the dot representing their autonomous Lexus described graceful arcs in accelerating laps as the company’s engineers pushed it faster and faster through the twisty course's 10 turns. These were the first runs of the day, meant to shake out any bugs, with a single human inside in case something went wrong.

PointOne isn’t really a self-driving-car company per se; the vehicle was just following hyper-precise waypoints along the track. The company's secret sauce, and the reason its GPS is much better than the one on your phone, is a network of proprietary beacons installed throughout the western US that corrects for the errors implicit in civilian GPS signals, tightening the margin of error to a few finger widths.

Back inside the Lexus, the autono­mous system is still taking us through every turn, but more slowly than strictly necessary. The track safety officer didn’t like the idea of our onboard photographer’s camera turning into a head-bashing projec­tile in the case of a crash, so he’d ordered the team to keep things slow.

Then comes turn 7. An almost 180-degree hairpin, this turn requires going wide to the right of the track, then cutting sharply to the left, hitting the tip of the wedge-like apex, and then proceeding to a sweeping turn 8.

“This one’s going to be a little fast,” Nathan announces from the back.

The car veers widely to the right, setting up the hairpin, but then doesn’t brake as it turns abruptly left and maintains its full straightaway speed.

Elijah Nouvelage

“No way this car is making this turn!” I think as I feel the car screechingly lose traction and drift rightward, the rest of the car trying and failing to follow the front wheels left.

“Bryan!” Nathan interjects from the back.

Galusha grabs the wheel, and just as the car starts to slide sideways off the track, he doesn’t commit the amateur move of doubling down on a bad turn and steering even further into it (thereby rolling the car) but instead straightens out. We shoot directly into the waterlogged patch of grass beyond the turn at around 30 mph, and just as the car bogs down in the grassy muck, cool-headed Galusha gives it a bit of gas to maintain momentum and brings us slowly back alongside pavement. There’s a pause as everyone catches their breath and regains normal consciousness again.

“That only happened because there’s a journalist here. It’s like demo gremlins,” I crack, trying to lighten the mood. Not many words are exchanged as the human, not the code, drives us back to the pits so we can see what went wrong.

"Throttle ... OK, brake ... Slight throttle ... Full throttle."

Racing coach Gregg Franklin is sitting in the passenger seat, and on account of the earplugs, helmets, and engine noise, every order is accompanied by a hand signal in my peripheral vision—bunched fist for brakes, a forward flat-hand salute for throttle—telling me which pedal to hit.

This time the driver is me, and I’m struggling to get my car, a 2017 Ford Focus RS (the racy version of the family hatchback), down the same racetrack without the benefit of precision GPS. A tenth of a meter? I’m not sure I’m even within the same zip code as the racing line, and Franklin constantly corrects my approaches to the course’s turns.

He also constantly gestures for more throttle, which I hit on sheer faith alone, as I’m not sure even the car’s sporty suspension and all-wheel drive will carry it around another screeching gyration.

Track racing involves alternately standing on the gas or the brake pedal the entire time, until your car reeks of brake and clutch and you’re covered in sweat and mentally exhausted. I’ve definitely reached that point when the checkered flag signals all of us to head back into the pits. On Franklin’s instructions, I do a few circles in the pits to let the brakes cool down, and then I get out and walk around to let myself do the same.

In the pits, the various teams continue futzing with the cars, oblivious to the various human-driven cars roaring away on the track. Many of the autonomous-vehicle founders and employees are (unsurprisingly) car enthusiasts themselves, so they’ve been sneaking a few laps with their own modded-out cars in between autonomous runs (as I had).

The vibe puts me in mind of the Homebrew Computer Club—the storied meetup where the two Steves (Jobs and Wozniak) first showed off the Apple I: informal, improvisational, and filled with a mix of hobbyists and entrepreneurs messing around in the early days of a transformative technology.

One car, a Kia Niro hybrid festooned with logos from another startup, PolySync, is being worked on by two different teams, each on one end of the car. A team from online learning startup Udacity, which offers a “nano” degree in autonomous-car engineering, is affixing a camera to the windshield.

A small gadget, called an inertial measurement unit (which is like the accelerometer in your phone) sits on its official mounting bracket—a coffee cup—in the center console. Back in the trunk, the founder of another startup called Qibus is messing with the remote driving technology they are developing, which allows you to drive a car anywhere from your laptop.

An inertial measurement unit—a device akin to the accelerometer in your phone—can detect a vehicle's motion, whether it's sliding, and its orientation with respect to the road.

David Robert Elliott

The ability for two teams to work on the same car is the point of PolySync’s technology (as well as a growing part of the autonomous world). Nestled under the driver’s seat is its DriveKit, a blinking box that takes electronic inputs like steering angle or brake and throttle, and translates them into actual movements of the car’s controls.

The fly-by-wire systems of modern cars mean that you no longer need actual mechanical force to drive a car: The feel in the steering wheel that makes you think you’re mechanically coupled to the front wheels (which you are, just barely) is a mostly artificial thing controllable via software. You really just need the right signals into the right wires to make the car do anything.

To prove the point, PolySync CTO Ken Keiter plugs an Xbox game controller into a laptop, connects that to his blinking box, and offers to take me around the track. Getting into the passenger seat for additional lulz, Keiter proceeds to steer the car from there using the game controller: left trigger button for brake, right trigger for throttle, and left-right on the joystick to move the wheel.

It’s a videogame come to life. With the right wireless technology (like the one in the trunk of the car), he could have been driving from the other side of the globe. Just another piece of the technological puzzle in this emerging industry.

Ken Keiter, the CTO of a startup called PolySync, operates a car using an Xbox game controller.

David Robert Elliott; Animation by WIRED Staff

Which is precisely the point. In the “mine for gold” vs. “sell picks and shovels to miners” trade-off of any booming startup ecosystem, many entrepreneurs opt to supply parts to companies toiling in the riskiest end of the business.

For another example of the same phenomenon, consider Warren Ahner, founder and CEO of Right Hook, which provides sophisticated testing and simulation software for autonomous vehicles. The company creates what’s effectively a Matrix for your driving algorithm: a simulated reality you plug into your software, allowing you to test it in the confines of code rather than on a busy urban street (or the Thunderhill raceway).

In addition to simulation, Right Hook’s algorithm allows fast-moving startups to perform so-called regression tests on their code. In a production environment, when engineers push a new code change, the software makes sure that prior logic stays correct: Critical mathematical calculations still need to spit out the right answers.

In the case of self-driving cars, that’s a vehicle not hitting a pedestrian on, say, a particularly complicated traffic circle. “You can see where your edge cases are, test them, and make them harder and harder as your code gets better and better,” Ahner says. The majors like Waymo and Uber test their vehicles over billions of miles of roadway, but the smaller companies can’t afford that, so Right Hook’s Matrix it is.

So: There are lots and lots of startups here, many of them either fielding cars or just nosing around the pits at the track, looking to fill in some blanks in the self-driving crossword.

The scene is like the Homebrew Computer Club, yes, but another historical parallel also presents itself. The early consumer internet was like the current batch of autonomous-vehicle hegemons. Today’s Waymo, Uber, and General Motors’ Cruise are reminiscent of incumbents like Compuserve and AOL: vertically integrated do-everything companies practically synonymous in users’ heads with their emerging industry. There might have been other technologies and protocols under the hood, so to speak, but the product presented itself as a titanic, unitary whole.

The scene is reminiscent of the Homebrew Computer Club but with cars.

The assembled entrepreneurs took advantage of a day at the track to test their own cars and skills on the raceway.

The Point One team uses a real-time map to track the progress of its vehicle.

The Udacity team affixes a camera to the Polysync car.

Polysync's CTO Ken Keiter tinkers with the DriveKit technology, which translates driving commands into actual movement of the car's controls.

Faraz Khan, left, has been hacking his Kia Soul so that it can be driven remotely.

Swift navigation's circuit board GPS unit.

The Point One car is loaded with gear.

The startup Qibus is working on tech that allows you to pilot a vehicle from a laptop.

Velodyne Lidar builds equipment that allows a vehicle to sense its environment.

The weekend-long event attracted a few spectators.

A company called Embark is working on semi-autonomous big rigs. This one was not allowed on the track itself because it was too heavy.

This turned out to be an illusion. The underlying modular nature of the internet soon revealed itself, with everyone and their sister biting off a piece of the integrated whole and then racing to seize horizontal market share for that slice of functionality, rather than assail the incumbents’ verticality.

Eventually, that AOL login refrain “You’ve got mail!” became nothing more than a Meg Ryan rom-com, as some companies seized the topmost layer that users see (Facebook), while others dominated the underlying plumbing (CloudFlare). The companies at the track event are effectively betting on a similar modularized collection of technologies eventually dominating the autonomous-vehicle biz, each of them owning some small layer of it.

This assumes, of course, that progress in self-driving cars, like that of the consumer internet, turns out to be valuable for an ever diversifying set of uses. In actual fact, everyone I speak to shares a muted despair at the slow progress that autonomous vehicles have made, not even remotely living up to their early promise. “This is the trough of disillusion­ment,” says PolySync’s Keiter, referring to the tech doldrums that often come between the precipitous hoopla of media coverage and funding rounds, and the eventual, slow upward progress of technology years later.

Insiders categorize a technology’s progress from level 1 autonomous driving—something basic like adaptive cruise control—to level 5, full Terminator-style automation where the software has total control. It’s clear that level 4 or 5 automation on city streets—the day your Uber driver disappears—isn’t happening anytime soon.

For now the progress is happening at narrower scales. For example, a company called Voyage is building fully autonomous cars for the controlled environment of retirement communities, those vast cities-within-cities of endless Spanish tile roofs and swimming pools in South Florida. By having set routes, changing on-the-ground infrastructure if need be, and (perhaps most importantly) providing remote human support to handle driving hiccups, the company hopes to provide the self-driving dream to retirees and expand from there. “Humans will be in the loop for a long, long time,” says Voyage CEO Oliver Cameron.

Human remote control is the tack taken by companies in another promising arena: long-haul trucking. Starsky Robotics is building a fleet of 18-wheelers that are semi-autonomous but remotely controlled by humans. Embark (which had a truck at the event—unfortunately, over the weight limit of the track) is building a fleet with level 2 autonomy that still features a human in the cab; one such vehicle recently completed a coast-to-coast trip.

In short, while much public attention is still focused on the futuristic city-driving dream, the real progress is often happening in transport niches largely out of view. One day, the technologies developed there will emerge, even if only as added safety features on (mostly) human-driven cars.

And how about in that other limited environment, somewhat more interesting than retirement communities—the racetrack?

A much bigger-budget version of the Thunderhill competition is getting underway with the unimaginatively named RoboRace, a racing concept using the same format as the electric-car Formula E series. Their first car is named (you guessed it) RoboCar and sports a pointed nose and flared, biplane-like fenders that vaguely resemble a Romulan warbird from Star Trek: The Next Generation.

Conspicuously absent is a cockpit; only a narrow, wasp-like backbone connects the front set of wheels to the rear one. The vehicle has completed closed-course, single-car time trials, but as with the homebrew cars at Thunderhill, even the big-ticket autonomous racing tech isn’t good enough for full-on, wheel-to-wheel racing alongside several cars. The next version of RoboRace’s car will feature a human safety driver inside, making it possible to put several cars on the track at once.

And my racing? How well did I manage against the various autonomous teams? Armed with good coaching and a speedy car but no actual track skills, I clocked an OK-but-not-amazing 1 minute, 48 seconds. The Point One team managed the fastest autonomous track time of 2 minutes, 6 seconds, a full 18 seconds slower than this human driver.

Unlike more cerebral arenas like chess or Go, humans still have the advantage behind the steering wheel—on the racetrack and on city streets. It was a milestone when IBM’s Deep Blue defeated chess master Gary Kasparov. But the machines have a long way to go before they can defeat us in driving contests of our own devising.

More Great WIRED Stories15 months of fresh hell inside FacebookCombatting drug deaths with opioid vending machinesWhat to expect from Sony's next-gen PlayStationHow to make your smart speaker as private as possibleMove over, San Andreas: There’s a new fault in town🏃🏽‍♀️ Looking for the best tools to get healthy? Check out our Gear team's picks for the best fitness trackers, running gear (including shoes and socks), and best headphones.📩 Get even more of our inside scoops with our weekly Backchannel newsletterRead More



Leave A Comment

More News

WIRED

GM's Big Upgrade, ‘Game of Thrones’' Unsatisfying End, 2019-05-20 19:50:47Catch up on the most important news from today in two minutes or less.

GM Gives All Its Vehicles a New Soul 2019-05-20 10:30:00GM's new "electronic platform" offers five times the bandwidth and compute power of its predecessor, to deliver better maps and new accessories.

Want to Bike Cross-Country? Some Old Rails Could 2019-05-19 07:00:00The Rails to Trails Conservancy is trying to assemble a 3,700-mile route that crosses 12 states. It needs help in Wyoming.

Another Fatal Tesla Autopilot Crash and More Car 2019-05-19 07:00:00The NTSB said a Tesla Model 3 had its Autopilot engaged when it collided with a truck in Florida in March, killing the driver.

Building a Bus Map When There Are No 2019-05-18 07:00:00Citizen groups in Beirut, Nairobi, Cairo and other cities are crowdsourcing maps of informal bus networks to encourage transit use.

A Fatal Tesla Autopilot Crash, Rising Methane Levels, 2019-05-16 18:33:42Catch up on the most important news today in two minutes or less.

Tesla’s Latest Autopilot Death Looks Just Like a 2019-05-16 17:46:31A Florida man was killed March 1 when his Tesla collided with a tractor trailer that was crossing its path. A government report says the Autopilot fea

Lilium's 36-Motor Flying Taxi Takes Off for the 2019-05-16 03:01:00The latest aircraft vying for a piece of the not-quite-realized aeromobility space takes a big step toward becoming a reality.

VW Will Make Its Own Batteries to Power 2019-05-15 17:53:18The German automaker plans 70 electric models by 2028. So it's building a gigafactory to ensure it has enough batteries.

Daimler Plans to Make Its Cars Carbon Neutral 2019-05-14 08:00:00The carmaker's new climate plan is bold—for a company. But it falls short of recommended emissions cuts and shows the limits of corporate self-

Why Uber Is Fighting Cities Over Data About 2019-05-13 07:00:00Los Angeles and other cities want detailed data on the shared scooters on their streets. Uber, Lyft and other companies fear a Trojan horse that could

Uber's Underwhelming IPO, Lyft Earnings and More Car 2019-05-12 09:00:00A decade after it was founded, Uber went public. Its shares fell almost 8% on their first day of trading.

Automotive News Breaking

GM's Maven pulls out of Chicago, New York 2019-05-20 16:26:55Maven, the mobility brand operated by GM, said its car-sharing service will remain in operation in Detroit and Los Angeles while it discontinues opera

Daimler to cut administration costs by 20%, report 2019-05-20 15:22:07Incoming boss Ola Kaellenius is working on a cost-cutting program, dubbed "Move," to reach profit margin targets threatened by trade talks and produ

GM moves closer to securing Missouri tax break 2019-05-20 14:13:18State senators passed incentives that would give GM $50 million in tax credits over 10 years in return for a $750 million investment to expand a light

Tesla shares, bonds take a hit as investors 2019-05-20 14:01:32Investors worry about the automaker's cash burn, sales outlook and problems with an Autopilot system that CEO Elon Musk has held out as key to the el

GM: Most vehicles to get over-the-air upgrade tech 2019-05-20 12:33:47The company's new electronic systems, designed to handle internet software downloads, will be capable of handling up to 4.5 terabytes of data pr

Jaguar Land Rover posts first profit in 4 2019-05-20 11:46:13Jaguar Land Rover expects cost reductions, led by job cuts, and a turnaround in China, where inventories have been trimmed, to shore up turnaround eff

Ford plans 7,000 salaried job cuts by September, 2019-05-20 09:15:52"Saying goodbye to colleagues is difficult," CEO Jim Hackett writes to employees.

U.S., Japan officials meeting to advance trade talks, 2019-05-20 08:07:06U.S. Trade Representative Robert Lighthizer will visit Japan on May 24 to meet Economy Minister Toshimitsu Motegi to accelerate trade talks ahead of a

Nissan's credit rating hit by negative outlook 2019-05-20 07:58:15S&P's move to place the automaker’s rating on negative watch follows a weaker earnings outlook and a heightened chance that Nissan's profi

Next Mitsubishi CEO says U.S. exit 'probably' not 2019-05-20 06:39:03Takao Kato, who helped establish Mitsubishi's joint manufacturing plant with Chrysler in Illinois some three decades ago, conceded Mitsubishi's U.S.

Uber slips below $70 billion value in turbulent 2019-05-11 07:58:32It took more than two hours for Uber shares to finally start trading after Uber executives and drivers congregated at the New York Stock Exchange for

China's BAIC seeks to buy 5% Daimler stake, 2019-05-11 07:39:03China's BAIC wants to buy a stake of up to 5 percent in Daimler as a way to secure its investment in Beijing Benz, the automakers' Chinese joint ven

Motor Trend

2020 Porsche Cayenne Coupe First Drive: Porsche’s Sportiest 2019-05-20 18:01:15Better late than never. Years after its German rivals launched cut-down versions of their mainstream SUVs, Porsche has finally got around to building

15 Cars That Won’t Disappoint You Like the 2019-05-20 17:38:02Like a lot of other people, we were pretty disappointed with the Game of Thrones finale. Half the things that happened made no sense, many of the

The Cheapest New SUVs You Can Buy in 2019-05-20 16:45:36It’s no secret that SUVs have gotten expensive, especially if you want the latest features and technology. A fully loaded Honda CR-V, for exampl

15 of the Best SUVs for Your Summer 2019-05-20 14:00:03Summer is here, which means it’s time to hit the road and get away from it all. An SUV is a good choice for road trips because they’re sup

Why the 2020 Lexus RC F Track Edition 2019-05-20 07:00:22When it first debuted, the Lexus RC was criticized for weighing two tons even in its more pedestrian versions. Thanks to a platform that utilizes part

2019 Toyota 86 TRD First Drive: Fair ’n‘ 2019-05-20 04:00:52Toyota Racing Development has prepared a special TRD edition of the 2019 Toyota 86. Don’t get excited, though: The upgrades are visual and chass

The 15 Smallest SUVs Currently on Sale 2019-05-20 04:00:41This segment didn’t really exist 10 years ago. As sedans and hatchbacks fall victim to the mighty force that is crossover fever, manufacturers c

2019 Acura RDX: 7 Design Details to Notice 2019-05-20 04:00:23Did your car’s design feel less special after months behind the wheel? Well, I can’t say the same for our 2019 Acura RDX, a MotorTrend lon

This 1995 Toyota Supra Makes 1,800 HP, Runs 2019-05-20 04:00:11Geovannie Castillo's 1995 Toyota Supra is making 1,800hp with stock heads and block, running 60 pinds of boost and spraying methanol! The post This 1

These are the Best Car Deals This Memorial 2019-05-20 04:00:05Memorial Day is one of the biggest car-shopping weekends of the year. Folks will have their tax-refund checks deposited, the weather is getting nice,

The Ford Focus ST Wagon and 8 Other 2019-05-19 04:00:36Ford just unveiled the second generation of the Focus ST Wagon, and unless you live outside the confines of the United States, you can’t have it

Tesla Model Y Styling Breakdown: A Designer’s Take 2019-05-18 04:00:20Elon Musk’s master plan has always had the Model 3 circled in fat red ink as Tesla’s mega-selling, do-or-die affordable car. But since the

Automotive news - from

Ford axing 7,000 white collar workers 2019-05-20 13:49:00Ford said on Monday (20 May) it was laying off about 7,000 workers, about 10% of its global workforce, as part of a restructuring plan designed to sav

ACEA still opposes US-proposed anti-WTO trade rules 2019-05-20 13:17:00The European Automobile Manufacturers' Association (ACEA) on Monday (20 May) reiterated its "opposition to any trade-restrictive measures that are i

Tata's Jaguar Land Rover back in the black 2019-05-20 11:49:00In a reversal of fortunes that surely will please owner Tata Motors, Britain's Jaguar Land Rover has booked a pre-tax profit after three consecutive

Higher costs hit Russian polymer supplier's Q1 result 2019-05-20 09:37:00Russia's R&P Polyplastic, which supplies polymer materials mainly to local automakers, said it booked a "considerable increase" in sales v

Denso eyes higher stake and powertrain sale to 2019-05-20 08:26:00Denso and powertrain supplier Aisan have reached a basic agreement, following a directors' meeting today (20 May) to begin studying increasing D

Honda R&D to collaborate with CiNet on mobility 2019-05-20 08:17:00Honda R&D, Honda Motor's research and development subsidiary announced it had begun to collaborate with the Center for Information and Neura

Mitsubishi and Here team on lane hazard warning 2019-05-20 07:34:00Mitsubishi Electric and Here Technologies have successfully piloted a system enabling vehicles to automatically warn others about upcoming road hazard

Renault unveils autonomous Ez-Pod 2019-05-20 06:41:00Renault has unveiled Ez-Pod, an exploratory electric and autonomous vehicle for on-demand travel across short distances.

Mercedes reveals new safety concept vehicle 2019-05-20 05:54:00Daimler's Mercedes-Benz Cars has unveiled a new concept/experimental vehicle to show off "safety ideas for a new mobility".

BorgWarner unveils Onboard Battery Charger 2019-05-20 05:41:00BorgWarner has unveiled its Onboard Battery Charger (OBC), adding to the company's portfolio of technologies for plug-in hybrid and pure-electric veh

Borealis opens new PP compounding plant in North 2019-05-17 12:32:00Borealis, which supplies polyolefins and base chemicals to the auto plastics industry, has officially opened a new polypropylene (PP) compounding plan

New US auto related tariffs on hold for 2019-05-17 12:23:00President Trump has officially set a six-month deadline to negotiate national security issues with respect to imported automobiles and certa


Disclaimer and Notice:WorldProNews.com is not responsible of these news or any information published on this website.