• Follow us


Can a Beatles Fan Believe in ‘Yesterday’?

Yesterday is a movie full of existential questions: What if the Beatles never happened? What if nobody knew their songs? Would people still fall in love without “Eight Days a Week” to show them how? Would people feel sorry for themselves without “For No One” or “You’ve Got To Hide Your Love Away” or “While My Guitar Gently Weeps”? And what if we heard their songs now for the first time? And, most importantly: What if some charmless guitar-slinging douchebag just happened to show up one day with 100 or so of the greatest songs ever written?

It’s a movie that turns these existential queries into a Fab Four-themed rom-com, written by the British titan of the genre Richard Curtis, who’s made the claim that “the Beatles have been the most important thing in my life.” He bends the premise into a straight-down-the-middle love story where a woman spends the whole movie begging for some attention from a guy way below her league. The plot is basically, “I’m just a Sexy Sadie, standing in front of a Hey Jude, asking him to And I Love Her.”

Related 100, Greatest, Beatles, Songs 100 Greatest Beatles Songs 'Yellow Submarine' at 50: Why the Psychedelic Animated Beatles Movie Is Timeless

“It’s not like a musical,” director Danny Boyle told Rolling Stone’s David Browne. “You’re not just covering the Beatles’ songs but recovering them from the dustbin of memory and re-presenting them to the world.” Imagine: An adult in 2019 thinking it’s necessary to rescue the Beatles from “the dustbin of memory.” But that’s the idea behind Yesterday.

Saving the Beatles from obscurity is a long and dotty Hollywood tradition. One of the Seventies’ most hyped flicks: The Bee Gees making a movie version of Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band, starring themselves as the band and Peter Frampton as Billy Shears. “Kids today don’t know the Beatles’ Sgt. Pepper,” Robin Gibb explained in 1977. “You see, there is no such thing as the Beatles. They don’t exist as a band and never performed Sgt. Pepper live, in any case. When ours comes out it will be, in effect, as if theirs never existed.”

Spoiler: Robin Gibb was slightly wrong about this.

People really thought this way in the Seventies, just as they do now. Hollywood gets frightful at the prospect of “kids today” forgetting the Beatles, who have never been in the slightest danger of being forgotten, least of all by kids, and whose music pimps itself better than anyone else has ever pimped it. So can a Beatles fan believe in Yesterday? Not surprisingly, it comes down to the music. The movie depends on the songs to carry the weight, and they deliver plenty of charm and emotion, even in the inferior remakes here. It’s a more enjoyable movie than the Bee Gees’ Sgt. Pepper, if only because it doesn’t have Steve Martin crooning “Maxwell’s Silver Hammer.”

Yesterday is the story of a sad sack named Jack (Hamish Patel), who gets hit by a bus and wakes up in a world where nobody knows about the Fabs except him. So he passes the songs off as his own, leading to fame and fortune. Nobody understands him except his lovesick manager Ellie, who keeps throwing herself at him until she’s got blisters on her fingers. (Ellie is played by the effervescent Lily James, a.k.a. Lady Rose on Downton Abbey, a.k.a. the young Meryl Streep in Mamma Mia! Here We Go Again.) She’s slightly too good for Jack, the way Paul McCartney was slightly too good for Denny Laine.

We are not talking about a Black Mirror episode here — there’s no attempt to have fun with the Twilight Zone possibilities. There’s no humor about the “butterfly effect” in erasing the Beatles from the world they changed. It’s a parallel universe where Coldplay and Neutral Milk Hotel exist without the Fabs, and where all the men have longish haircuts that would have been unthinkable before the mop tops came along. As British critic Dorian Lynskey noted, “‘A world without the Beatles is a world that’s infinitely worse,’ says one character, in a film where a world without the Beatles is almost exactly the same.”

The unfixed hole at the heart of Yesterday is the leading man, or lack thereof. Jack doesn’t have the charm, humor or charisma of Neil Aspinall, much less the Beatles. It’s hard to tell if Patel (famous from the British soap EastEnders) is an awful actor or it’s just a drearily conceived part, but as George put it so eloquently in A Hard Day’s Night, he’s a drag, a well-known drag. Jack’s only likeable quality is that he’s into the Pixies (he has their poster on his wall) and wears a Fratellis T-shirt. Honestly, the idea of a world where nobody knows the Beatles is nowhere near as surreal as a world where people remember the Fratellis. (Note: I love the Fratellis, and could sing their 2006 U.K. hit “Chelsea Dagger” for you right now.)

Yesterday would have been a much livelier tale if Ellie were the one with the guitar and Jack were her dour, no-fun manager. She has more of the Beatles’ spark. There’s a scene where Ellie joins him in the studio, banging her tambourine, singing along, and it’s an electric moment — ah yes, a rock group, people making music together. Then the moment ends, and Yesterday turns back into the continuing story of the grumpy dude with an acoustic guitar. But it continues the weirdest and most noxious trend in the nouveau breed of rock flicks, like A Star Is Born, Bohemian Rhapsody, The Dirt: there is never the slightest suggestion that female musicians exist. The idea just never comes up. (In A Star Is Born, when Gaga sleeps under a Carole King album cover, it’s a shock because Carole is the only other female presence in the movie who listens to music, much less performs it.)

Ed Sheeran gets the funniest moment, where he gives Jack notes on a song and convinces him to change it to “Hey Dude” — the movie could have used a lot more of that irreverent cheek. Ed is easily the film’s most enjoyable presence, willing to mock himself. There’s a scene where he banters on the plane with a roadie — “You might be right, enjoy the flight.” That’s an arcane in-joke for Swifties, based on Ed and Taylor’s bedtime texts. (“Like you said, Ed.” “That’s okay, Tay.”) It stands out because it’s one of the few moments where 21st century pop is acknowledged at all. (And it gives the pop girls in the theater a chance to one-up their know-it-all dads.) Kate McKinnon is hilarious hamming it up as an industry shark — the equivalent of Victor Spinetti in the Beatles’ flicks.

If you’re a hard-line pedantic Beatleologist, actively looking for things to hate, you won’t find any Bohemian Rhapsody-style factual gaffes to cluck over. (I say that as someone who actively enjoyed the errors in BoRhap — they were the comic highlights of the movie.) The closest thing is when Jack visits Liverpool to see the grave of Eleanor Rigby, a grave none of the Beatles ever visited or knew existed. It wasn’t until the Eighties anyone noticed there was a real-life Eleanor Rigby buried near Liverpool. When Paul wrote the song, he just made the name up. (Still, the grave does exist, and Paul recalls sneaking into that churchyard to party with John, so it’s a legit coincidence.)

Yesterday barely presents any of the songs in full, as if they felt we’d get bored after a verse or two. It takes nearly half the movie to get to any George songs, to the point where you start worrying they forgot George was in the band; when Jack visits L.A., we get snippets of “Here Comes The Sun” and “Something.” (But not George’s ode to L.A., “Blue Jay Way.”) The idea of “I Want To Hold Your Hand” as a solo folkie showcase is just absurd — the song is designed for hormonally crazed lunatics to scream together. The only singer in history to get away with a solo vocal on “I Want To Hold Your Hand” is Al Green, and no, Hamish Patel is not quite in Reverend Al’s league. At the very end of the movie, we get one complete song in its original Beatle performance. By then, you’re so hungry to hear the whole band, you want to stay for the credits.

But nothing about Jack’s rise to fame makes sense, really. He plays “Back in the U.S.S.R.” in Moscow without changing a word. (Fun fact: The Ukraine and Russia are no longer the same country! Thousands of people have been killed fighting over this!) There are no teenage girls in his audience, even though teenage girls invented the Beatles and everything halfway cool ever since. For a prototypical Beatle fan in 2019, just look to Emma Gonzalez, the Florida teen who became a gun-control (and LGBTQ) activist last year. She’s a Ringo stan who loves to wear her Fabs shirt in TV interviews and wrote on Twitter, “I feel like Beatles songs were made to be sung by powerful women.” Like so many fans, yesterday and today, she was only waiting for this moment to arise.

It never even enters Jack’s mind to use these songs to court women, which is weird because John, Paul, George and Ringo never made any effort to pretend that wasn’t their prime motivation. “Michelle” is a ditty Paul wrote in his teens for the specific purpose of impressing art-school girls at Liverpool parties by pretending he was French. As he says in the bio Many Years From Now, “Me trying to be enigmatic to make girls think, ‘Who’s that very interesting French guy over in the corner?'” But to Jack, it’s just another song title on just another Post-It on his wall.

For the Beatles, their music was all about communicating with women, either in their lives or in their audience. As Paul told Beatle scholar Mark Lewisohn in 1987, “At the time we were 18, 19, whatever, so you’re talking to all girls who are 17. We were quite conscious of that. We wrote for our market. We knew that if we wrote a song called ‘Thank You Girl’ that a lot of the girls who wrote us fan letters would take it as a genuine thank you.” That’s why he and John tried to load their songs with pronouns. “We were aware that that happened when you sang to an audience. So ‘From Me to You,’ ‘Please Please Me,’ ‘She Loves You.’ Personal pronouns. We always used to do that.”

What Paul couldn’t have imagined — nobody could have, nobody did — is that all these years later, people all over the world would hear themselves in those songs. Or more to the point: We would hear ourselves in these songs. To me, that’s the most beautiful, mysterious and disturbing part of the Beatles story — the way they just kept getting bigger and bigger after they broke up, to the point where they’re much more famous and beloved today than they were in the Sixties. The world kept dreaming the Beatles, long after the boys in the band thought the dream was over. The ex-Beatles found this baffling, even infuriating, but they had to live in a world that was madly in love with the Beatles, the way we all do.

Yesterday is set in a world where that love story supposedly never happened — yet the songs keep reminding you why the story never ends. As a great man or four once sang, it’s a love that lasts forever. It’s a love that has no past.

In This Article: Beatles, Danny Boyle

Want more Rolling Stone? Sign up for our newsletter.

Read More

Leave A Comment

More News

Rolling Stone Latest Movies

‘Midsommar’ Review: Pagan Horror Gets a New Classic 2019-07-02 11:18:06Filmmaker Ari Aster's follow-up to 'Hereditary' turns a break-up story into a funny, frightening 'Wicker Man' 2.0

Can a Beatles Fan Believe in ‘Yesterday’? 2019-07-01 11:36:54Our resident hardcore Beatleologist on why this fantasy about a Fab Four-less world should have fixed its holes

‘Jumanji: The Next Level’ Trailer Puts Clever Spin 2019-07-01 11:12:39Danny DeVito and Danny Glover transform into Dwayne Johnson and Kevin Hart in sequel to 2017 reboot

‘Spider-Man: Far From Home’ Review: The Webslinger Swings 2019-07-01 10:54:55Tom Holland saves this decent enough Spidey movie set in a post-'Endgame' MCU

Why ‘The Queen’ Documentary Is an Essential Queer 2019-06-28 12:37:48Intimate 1968 portrait of gender pioneers returns to screens for Pride month — and its rightful place in the LGBTQ pantheon

The Last Word: John Waters on Censorship, Smoking 2019-06-27 13:46:21With a new book called 'Mr. Know-It-All' out now, the People's Pervert goes deep on the things that make him tick

New Ariana Grande, Miley Cyrus, Lana Del Rey 2019-06-27 09:53:03Upcoming franchise reboot stars Kristen Stewart, Naomi Scott, Ella Balinska

‘Maiden’ Review: An All-Female Crew’s Sail of the 2019-06-27 09:00:12Documentary on the 1989 yacht crew who beat the odds to win a major race and knocked the sexist world of sailing on its ass

Ian McKellen Keeps Dark Secrets From Helen Mirren 2019-06-26 14:38:48McKellan stars as a con man out for Mirren's money

Best Movies to See in July: ‘Once Upon 2019-06-26 10:06:37From Quentin Tarantino's epic valentine to Tinseltown to a feline Beyoncé and a new Webslinger adventure

Watch Bride Battle Husband’s Insane Family in New 2019-06-17 13:19:23Film stars Samara Weaving, Mark O'Brien, Adam Brody, Andie MacDowell, Henry Czerny

Franco Zeffirelli, ‘Romeo and Juliet’ Director, Dead at 2019-06-15 12:01:11Italian filmmaker known for his Shakespeare adaptations, renowned opera productions


AGENTS OF SHIELD: Season 6, Episode 8: Collision 2019-07-02 11:30:51  Agents of Shield Collision Course (Part 1) Trailer and Episode 9-10 Synopses ABC‘s Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.: Season 6, Episode 8: Collision

SUITS: Season 9 TV Show Trailer: The Final 2019-07-02 10:00:44  Suits Season 9 Trailer USA‘s Suits: Season 9 TV show trailer has been released and stars Patrick J. Adams, Gabriel Macht, Katherine Heigl

Disney Television Studios San Diego Comic-Con 2019 Panels: 2019-07-02 08:30:04  Disney Television Studios San Diego Comic-Con 2019 Panels A press release has been issued for Disney Television Studios’ San Diego Comic-

EUPHORIA: Season 1, Episode 4: Shook One Pt. 2019-07-02 07:00:19  Euphoria Shook One Pt. II Trailer HBO‘s Euphoria: Season 1, Episode 4: Shook One Pt. II TV show trailer has been released and stars Zenda

THE BOYS (2019) TV Show Featurette & TV 2019-07-01 18:13:49  The Boys TV Show Featurette and TV Spot A TV show featurette and a new TV show commercial for The Boys (2019) have been released Amazon Prime.

JUMANJI: THE NEXT LEVEL (2019) Movie Trailer: The 2019-07-01 12:40:30  Jumanji: The Next Level Trailer Jake Kasdan‘s Jumanji: The Next Level (2019) movie trailer has been released by Sony Pictures and stars D

Box Office: June 28-30, 2019: TOY STORY 4, 2019-07-01 09:00:08  Box Office June 28-30, 2019 Toy Story 4 was the Number One film at the box office for the second weekend in a row with $57.9 Million for $236.9

THE GOOD LIAR (2019) Movie Trailer: Ian McKellen 2019-07-01 08:00:52  The Good Liar Trailer Bill Condon‘s The Good Liar (2019) movie trailer has been released and stars Ian McKellen, Helen Mirren, Russell To

Box Office: June 14-16, 2019: MEN IN BLACK 2019-06-16 20:25:11  Box Office June 14-16, 2019Men in Black International premiered in the Number One spot at the box office over the weekend with $28.5 Million in

ANNA (2019) International Movie Trailer 2: Sasha Luss 2019-06-16 19:25:44  Anna International Trailer 2 The second international movie trailer of Anna (2019) has been released by Summit Entertainment. The first movie t

EUPHORIA (2019) TV Show Trailer 3; Episode 1-6 2019-06-16 18:25:26  Euphoria Trailer 3 and Episode 1-6 Plot Synopses, Titles, and Air Dates The third TV show trailer for Euphoria (2019) and the official plot syn

Film Casting: ONE LONG NIGHT, EVERYBODY’S TALKING ABOUT 2019-06-16 08:46:04  One Long Night, Everybody’s Talking About Jamie, Waldo, and more Film Casting NewsOne Long Night, Everybody’s Talking About Jamie,

NYT > Movies

‘Midsommar’ Review: Building a Horror Møusetrap With Swedish 2019-07-02 18:38:35Ari Aster’s hyper-aware movie about bad relationships and worse vacations has more virtuosity than vision.

‘Yesterday’ Star Himesh Patel Was Delivering Papers Not 2019-07-02 14:32:10When he was a soap opera regular, his parents insisted that he have a paper route to keep him grounded. That lasted till he was 21.

In ‘Mikey and Nicky,’ Elaine May Nails a 2019-07-02 11:21:24Newly restored, May’s darkest comedy is one of the great underappreciated American movies of the 1970s.

Review: ‘Spider-Man: Far From Home’ Is the Latest 2019-07-02 00:53:11Peter Parker deals with teenage angst and lingering Stark Industries H.R. issues while trying to enjoy a trip to Europe.

‘Toy Story 4’ Is Bigger Than the Beatles 2019-07-01 17:31:57After a solid second weekend, the movie’s global total has hit $496.5 million. “Yesterday” landed in third place.

Bob Dorian, Genial Guide to Old Films on 2019-07-01 16:49:21A movie buff since childhood, Mr. Dorian was an actor, a magician and a disc jockey before joining the channel as prime-time host in 1984.

Review: Hugh Jackman Isn’t Quite the Greatest Showman 2019-07-01 16:48:20His world tour “The Man. The Music. The Show.” stopped at Madison Square Garden. But it would have been better on Broadway.

Isabel Sarli, Popular Star of Racy Argentine Films, 2019-07-01 15:06:01Ms. Sarli reached international audiences in dozens of movies that were the bane of censors, starting with one in which she appeared fully nude.

The Long and Winding Road to ‘Yesterday,’ a 2019-07-01 14:52:10Want to make a movie about the enduring power of the Beatles? You’ll need a lot of their songs, and more than a little help from your friends.

‘A Bundle of Action’ and ‘Just the Right 2019-07-01 11:20:45Young moviegoers weigh in on the much-anticipated Pixar sequel.

‘Yesterday’ | Anatomy of a Scene 2019-07-01 10:53:07Danny Boyle narrates a sequence from his film.

Tom Hiddleston to Star in Broadway Revival of 2019-06-30 23:17:30Jamie Lloyd’s production of Harold Pinter’s romantic triangle is transferring this fall after a sold-out London run.

L.A. Times - Movie News

Harry Styles as Elvis Presley? He’s a top 2019-07-02 13:25:00After much conversation, Warner Bros. is taking action to cast its lead for Baz Luhrmann’s upcoming Elvis Presley biopic. According to the Holly

Revisiting ‘Forrest Gump’ at 25 — what made 2019-07-02 10:00:00In 1994, moviegoers flocked to “The Flintstones” and “Maverick” in May, and “Speed” and “The Lion King&rdquo

Review: In the unsettling ‘Midsommar,’ the nightmare unfolds 2019-07-01 18:25:00The setting of “Midsommar,” a luxuriant deep-tissue freakout from writer-director Ari Aster, is a picturesque commune in Hälsingland,

CAA becomes third agency to take Writers Guild 2019-07-01 15:15:00CAA has filed an antitrust lawsuit against the Writers Guild of America, becoming the third Hollywood talent agency to take the union to court over th

Film academy invites more women than men to 2019-07-01 14:45:00As of Monday, there are a whole lot more people in Hollywood who’d like to thank the academy. In its latest step toward diversifying its histori

Taylor Swift rages on the news of Scooter 2019-06-30 17:20:00Taylor Swift took to Tumblr on Sunday to express her frustration over news that her master recordings had been acquired by music manager Scooter Braun

‘Toy Story’ remains on top, ‘Annabelle 3’ and 2019-06-30 13:50:00Toys continued to dominate the box office for a second consecutive weekend with "Toy Story 4" maintaining its position at the top of the charts and

Meet ‘The Last Black Man in San Francisco’ 2019-06-29 10:00:00Like the pastors and storytellers in his life he credits with igniting his early artistic spark, Jonathan Majors is given to spinning bright bursts of

Writers Guild sends cease and desist letter to 2019-06-28 20:20:00After being slapped this week with lawsuits from two of Hollywood’s biggest talent agencies, the Writers Guild of America fired back on Friday,

Indie Focus: Climb on board with 'Maiden' 2019-06-28 17:00:00Hello! I’m Mark Olsen. Welcome to another edition of your regular field guide to a world of Only Good Movies. Anyone looking to celebrate the up

The captain of the Maiden talks about how 2019-06-28 16:10:00Thirty years ago, Tracy Edwards and her female crew made history when they entered the male-dominated world of the Whitbread Round the World yacht rac

New video: ‘Transit’ is another provocative thriller from 2019-06-28 08:00:00New on Blu-ray “Transit” (Music Box DVD, $29.95; Blu-ray, $34.95; also available on VOD) German director Christian Petzold has made some o

CinemaBlend Latest Content

Regal Cinemas Is Going The MoviePass Route 2019-07-03 19:25:11Another option for avid moviegoers is on the way.

Ruby Roundhouse Will Get Some Changes In Jumanji: 2019-07-03 18:45:02Alright then, Jumanji. Keep your secrets.

Kevin Feige Still Likes It When Marvel Gets 2019-07-03 18:01:20The Marvel Studios president enjoys surprising people and blowing away expectations.

Chris Evans Thinks The MCU Will Eventually Answer 2019-07-03 17:38:49More from Chris Evans this time on all that timey wimey stuff.

Zendaya, Zac Efron, And Other Movie Stars Who 2019-07-03 17:06:58Here's a bulk of Hollywood's elite movie stars who first captured audience's attention on the Disney Channel.

How James Franco Got Roped Into Johnny Depp 2019-07-03 16:00:41The star of The Deuce may find himself drawn in to the former couple's nasty and protracted legal battle.

Disney’s Live Action Little Mermaid Has Cast Its 2019-07-03 15:44:18This actress is going to be part of a new world.

That Time Spider-Man’s Flash Thompson Auditioned To Play 2019-07-03 15:37:49Somewhere in another Multiverse maybe this actually happened!

Disney Deletes Controversial Toy Story 2 Scene 2019-07-03 15:27:17This scene... didn't age well.

Walt Disney World Is Closing Several Epcot Locations 2019-07-03 14:28:28Get ready for a lot of changes coming to Epcot.

Rami Malek On Refusing To Play A Religious 2019-07-03 13:57:53Born of Egyptian parents, the Mr. Robot actor was worried about playing a villain at first.

Wait, Is Quentin Tarantino Done With Movies After 2019-07-03 13:51:16The director has a self-imposed cap of 10 films, but could he decide to call it a career early?

Disclaimer and Notice:WorldProNews.com is not responsible of these news or any information published on this website.