• Follow us

Gadgets

Panasonic Lumix S1 vs. Canon EOS R: Full-Frame Mirrorless Matchup | Digital Trends

Previous Next Panasonic Lumix S1 Daven Mathies/Digital Trends Canon EOS R Review Gannon Burgett/Digital Trends

The Canon EOS R and Panasonic Lumix S1 both represent their company’s first attempts at full-frame mirrorless cameras, and each manufacturer brings different competencies to the table. Canon has made many full-frame DSLRs before, while the S1 was Panasonic’s first full-frame camera, period. Panasonic has had much more experience building mirrorless cameras, however, having essentially founded the modern mirrorless era in 2008 with the Lumix G1.

So which company made the better first-generation camera? Looking at the spec sheet, the Lumix S1 stands out in some key areas, but it can be hard to determine a true winner. Further muddying the waters is the fact that the EOS R costs $500 less at the time of writing, thanks to a $300 rebate. At the full retail price of $2,300, compared to the S1 at $2,500, the decision would be a bit easier. We’ve fully reviewed both cameras, and here are our thoughts on how they compare, from autofocus performance to image quality to video features.

Panasonic Lumix S1

panasonic lumix s1r vs s1 product comparison

Canon EOS R

panasonic lumix s1 vs canon eos r product comparison

Sensor 24-megapixel, full-frame sensor with 96MP high-resolution mode 30-megapixel full-frame sensor Burst speed 9 fps (6 with AF-C) 8 fps (5 fps with continuous AF) Shutter speed 1/8,000 to 60 sec. 1/8000 to 30 sec. ISO 100-51,200 (50-204,800 expanded) 100 – 40,000 (50-102,400 expanded) Autofocus 225-point contrast-detection DFD AF Dual Pixel phase detection AF with up to 5,655 points Image stabilization 5-axis sensor-shift stabilization (None, available in many lenses) Video 4K/30p, 4K/60p with 1.5x crop, HLG (10-bit V-Log via firmware update) 4K/30 with 1.7x crop (C-Log and 10-bit output) Viewfinder 5.7m-dot OLED EVF 3.7m-dot OLED EVF LCD 3.2-inch, 2.1m-dot tilting touchscreen 3.15-inch, 2.1m-dot tilting touchscreen Connectivity Wi-Fi, Bluetooth Wi-Fi, Bluetooth Media slots 1 SD, 1 XQD (CFexpress support coming) 1 SD Battery Li-ion rated for 380 shots Li-ion rated at 330 shots Dimensions (WxHxD) 5.87 x 4.33 x 3.82 inches 5.35 x 3.87 x 3.32 inches Weight 35.8 ounces 23.4 ounces Kit lens Available body only or with 24-105mm f/4 Available body only or with a 24-105mm f/4 Price $2,500 (MSRP, body-only) $2,300 (MSRP, body-only) Read more Panasonic Lumix S1 review Canon EOS R review Buy now Amazon Walmart Sensor

A quick glance at the spec sheet and you might think the Canon comes out ahead here, with 30 megapixels compared to the Lumix’s 24. Sure, that’s arguably not a very big difference, but it will leave photographers with slightly more room to crop.

But that’s hardly the full story. If it’s maximum detail you’re after, the Lumix S1 has a high-resolution mode that creates a 96MP composite image from eight separate exposures. It can do this thanks to the sensor-shift stabilization system, which moves the sensor by half a pixel’s width in between exposures to capture additional detail, reduce the chance of moiré, and push beyond the limitations of the Bayer filter design.

High-resolution mode requires a tripod and a perfectly still subject, however, so while it’s great for landscapes and architecture, it can’t really be used for portraits, wildlife, or sports.

panasonic lumix s1 vs canon eos r portrait woman roaring 20s Canon EOS R Sample Photos 1. Shot on Lumix S1 2. Shot on Canon EOS R

But that’s not the only advantage the S1 has. Its lower resolution actually helps it produce cleaner images in low light, with a maximum native ISO of 51,200, 1/3 stop above the EOS R, or a boosted maximum of 204,800, a full stop above the Canon. DxOMark’s objective measurements also put the S1 a stop above the EOS R for dynamic range at base ISO. Of course, how much of that is noticeable in the real world is debatable and depends on the scene, but the S1 sensor is capable of delivering the best of both worlds between sensitivity and resolution, putting it ahead of the Canon here.

Winner: Lumix S1

Speed

When it comes to continuous shooting performance, both the Canon and the Lumix are pretty even and are limited in similar ways, but the S1 has a slight edge. Both with and without continuous autofocus, the S1 performs 1 frame per second faster than the EOS R. It can hit a maximum of 9 fps, or 6 with continuous AF, while the Canon tops out at 8 fps, or 5 with continuous AF.

Perhaps more importantly, the S1 has a larger image buffer that can hold 75 RAW files based on our testing. The EOS R’s buffer depth is advertised at 47 RAWs, although independent tests have put it up to 65. Thanks to its high-speed XQD card, the S1 will also be faster to write those images from the buffer to the memory card, limiting downtime between high speed bursts.

To be clear, neither camera is going to offer the type of speed professional sports shooters need, but the S1 is the more capable when it comes to continuous shooting.

Winner: Lumix S1

Autofocus

Canon’s Dual Pixel Autofocus (DPAF) is one of the best autofocus technologies we’ve ever tested, and on the EOS R it offers over 5,000 individual phase-detect focus points that work together to ensure pinpoint-accurate results. It works incredibly well for both single-shot and continuous autofocus modes, although processing the data from all of those points is one reason why the EOS R’s burst rate drops to 5 fps with continuous AF on.

Panasonic’s own focusing technology, Depth from Defocus (DFD), relies instead on contrast detection, a type of autofocus that, while accurate, is traditionally much slower than phase detection. Thanks to some clever engineering, Panasonic has found a way to speed it up considerably — in the majority of situations, it is only negligibly slower than competing phase-detection systems. The S1 also boasts an impressive subject recognition mode that can track eyes, faces, and even some animals. However, we did run into occasional issues with focus hunting, something that could make you miss the critical moment.

Since DFD is essentially reliant on software alone, without a hardware component other than the imaging pixels themselves, Panasonic will likely find ways to improve it over time through firmware updates. For now, however, the EOS R has the edge.

Winner: Canon EOS R

Design Panasonic Lumix S1 Canon EOS R Review

This is a hard category to judge objectively, and we always recommend getting your hands on a camera before buying it, if at all possible. What feels right to one person may feel completely off to another.

There are, however, certain design features that appeal to high-end enthusiast and professional photographers, and both of these cameras are targeting such users. To this end, we have to conclude that the Panasonic S1 offers the more capable and complete design, with more buttons and dials, a higher-resolution electronic viewfinder, and dual card slots. It also feels more robust and better made, although we can’t say for certain if it will hold up to weather or professional wear and tear any better than the Canon.

Of course, all of that comes at a cost to weight. With the battery loaded, the Lumix S1 weighs more than some professional DSLRs. If your idea of a mirrorless camera includes the descriptor “lightweight,” you may prefer the Canon, which weighs just 23.4 ounces compared to the Lumix at nearly 39. The EOS R also has a unique touch slider (pictured above) which can be programmed to control different camera settings. It’s not a feature everyone loves, but it’s worth pointing out. Still, if control, durability, and capability are what you’re after, go with the Lumix.

Winner: Lumix S1

Stabilization

While Canon offers optical stabilization on a number of its RF lenses, the EOS R does not have in-body image stabilization. The Lumix S1 uses a 5-axis sensor-shift stabilization system which, in addition to powering the high-resolution mode, provides up to 6 stops of shake reduction. It can be combined with stabilized lenses for even better performance.

In-body stabilization is something Panasonic has done for a while now in its Micro Four Thirds mirrorless systems, so it knows the technology well. Canon has yet to produce a camera with in-body stabilization, although the company has commented that it will bring the feature to future EOS R series models. For now, this is another point clearly in the Lumix S1’s basket.

Winner: Lumix S1

Video

Panasonic is well known as a video company, and the Lumix GH series (built on the smaller Micro Four Thirds format) continues to present us with some of the best video cameras you can buy. The Lumix S1 isn’t really targeting that same audience, but it still packs a punch when it comes to video features. Even compared to the more expensive Lumix S1R, it has some pretty big advantages. It can shoot oversampled 4K/30 from the full width of the sensor with no time limit, or 4K/60 from an APS-C crop with a 30-minute time limit. It can also record 10-bit video, but only in the Hybrid Log Gamma (HLG) mode, while a future paid firmware update will allow for 10-bit V-Log to be recorded both internally and externally.

While the EOS R was the first Canon to receive both C-log and 10-bit output, the camera is significantly limited in other ways when it comes to video. Firstly, 4K is recorded from a severe 1.7X cropped region of the sensor, effectively smaller than even an APS-C sensor would be. Next, it suffers from pretty bad rolling shutter, a problem that can be exacerbated by the lack of in-body image stabilization. While we were actually pleased with the quality of colors out of the EOS R, it’s very hard to recommend it as a video camera, especially when the competition is so strong.

Winner: Lumix S1

Battery life

Neither of these cameras advertise strong battery life, but the S1’s massive 3,050mAh battery helps it eke out a few additional photos over the EOS R with a rating of 380 shots compared to 330. That big battery, of course, is one reason why the S1 weighs so much. For what it’s worth, the EOS R is certainly more efficient — it pulls its 330 exposures from a battery with just 1,800mAh.

Perhaps because Panasonic engineers realized how much power the Lumix S1’s 5.7-million-dot EVF was going to consume, the camera also features a special Power Save Live View Finder (LVF) Shooting mode, which somewhat mimics how a DSLR manages power. In this mode, the camera will go to sleep after a short time, but will leave some functions active, like the EVF eye sensor and shutter button. Battery life is stated as over 1,000 exposures in this mode.

Winner: Lumix S1

Lenses

You could call this in either camera’s favor, depending on your point of view. The Lumix S1 is built around the Leica L mount, which already has a collection of Leica lenses for it — but they may be prohibitively expensive (they’re made by Leica, after all). Additionally, Sigma has signed on to develop L-mount lenses, with 11 of their acclaimed Art-series lenses currently on the way. Of the three Lumix S lenses currently available from Panasonic, the S Pro 50mm f/1.4 is also one of the best 50mm lenses we’ve ever seen — of course, at $2,300, it should be.

Canon is in a different boat, being the sole brand behind its new RF mount (it also has an excellent 50mm, with an even faster f/1.2 aperture, also at $2,300). Undoubtedly, third-party manufacturers will step up with lenses for the system, but for now, you’re left with a fairly limited (and quite expensive) collection.

On the plus side, you can mount any Canon EF lens — that is, those made for the company’s DSLRs — on the EOS R via an adapter. The lenses remain fully compatible and, in our testing, offered nearly identical autofocus performance. Yes, this somewhat negates the smaller form factor of the mirrorless body, but it does mean there is a wide assortment of lenses available at a variety of prices.

So, the S1 currently has more lenses available that don’t require an adapter, but may be above your budget, while the EOS R has fewer native lenses, but more total lenses if you count those that can be easily adapted to it. We’ll give this one to the Canon, because the lack of affordable lenses is a current sore point in the Lumix S series, but if you’ve got the budget for it, you can find some excellent glass for the S1.

Winner: Canon EOS R

Picking an overall winner Panasonic Lumix S1 Canon EOS R Review

The Lumix S1 is almost two cameras in one. It’s a hybrid still/video machine with excellent low-light performance from its 24MP sensor, as well as an ultra-high-resolution camera capable of shooting 96MP images when you need detail over speed. It also has an absolutely gorgeous EVF, dual memory cards, and expertly designed control layout that is built to hold up to professional use. It would seem the pretty clear winner here.

However, the EOS R is not without some advantages. The autofocus system is among the best we’ve ever seen and, at the time of writing, it’s significantly less expensive than the S1. That could make it a more valuable buy; but if money is no object, we have to lean toward the Lumix.

Editors' Recommendations Read More



Leave A Comment

More News

Digital Trends

Oculus Quest review New! 2019-05-21 16:50:19Oculus announced that its Project Santa Cruz virtual reality headset will ship next year as the Oculus Quest, and we got to try out several new game t

Wyze’s next ultra-affordable smart device is an $8 New! 2019-05-21 16:50:01Budget smart home device manufacturer Wyze has done it again, announcing Tuesday that it is taking orders on an $8 smart light bulb. The bulb, now ava

What is a mirrorless camera, and what makes New! 2019-05-21 16:40:52What exactly is a mirrorless camera, and what makes them so special? In this article, we break down the specifics of mirrorless cameras, including how

Many Uber and Lyft vehicles have open safety New! 2019-05-21 16:32:06A Consumer Reports survey of roughly 94,000 cars registered with Uber and Lyft in New York City and Seattle found that many had open safety recalls. T

Elon Musk thinks Starlink satellite internet could be New! 2019-05-21 16:21:20Elon Musk's ultra-ambitious Starlink space internet project may take until November 2027 to be fully operational. However, some level of service coul

Why you shouldn’t mount your TV above your New! 2019-05-21 16:01:22Mounting a TV above your fireplace may be popular and it might even seem appealing, but we have some concerns. We've got a list of reasons why placin

Looking to upgrade? These are the best iPhone New! 2019-05-21 15:55:21Apple devices can get expensive, but if you just can't live without iOS, don't despair: We've curated an up-to-date list of all of the absolute bes

Digital Trends Live: Google’s new Glass, Impossible Sausage, New! 2019-05-21 15:45:42On Tuesday's episode of DT Live, we discuss Google’s new version of Glass, the Impossible Sausage debuts at Little Caesar’s, the post off

Want to Alexa-enable your phone landline? Amazon’s Echo New! 2019-05-21 15:11:17Do you still have a landline, or have VoIP in your home? We've spotted a good deal on the Echo Connect, Amazon's phone adapter which connects your h

How to use Plex to manage and play New! 2019-05-21 14:58:30If you want a Netflix-like experience for the media you already own, you need Plex. It's the free media center software that automatically catalogs a

Sony’s next-gen PlayStation Now vision includes games streaming New! 2019-05-21 14:40:00Sony has made the topics from the yearly investor relations meeting available to the public and now we have an even clearer picture of what the PlaySt

The best OnePlus 7 Pro screen protectors to New! 2019-05-21 14:30:39The OnePlus 7 Pro has a stunning Fluid AMOLED display that's absolutely worth gazing at. But it's not going to be pleasant if cracks obscure your vi

Engadget RSS Feed

Tfue's lawsuit against FaZe has been a long New! 2019-05-21 16:14:00Turner Tenney is the most popular Fortnite player in the world. He plays as Tfue on YouTube and Twitch, where there's a small red logo for FaZe Clan,

A sixth of ridesharing cars have unfixed safety New! 2019-05-21 15:38:00It's not just ridesharing drivers that merit some safety concerns -- the car might be a risk as well. Consumer Reports has conducted a study indicat

California's Senate may ban facial recognition tech in New! 2019-05-21 14:52:00The state of California's legislature is considering a new bill that would ban the use of facial recognition technology in police body cameras, accor

Comcast is working on a health-focused motion sensor New! 2019-05-21 14:08:00Even telecom giants can't resist the temptation to hop on the smart speaker bandwagon... or can they? CNBC sources say the news site's parent compan

Samsung Galaxy Home mini surfaces in FCC filing New! 2019-05-21 13:55:00The Galaxy Home smart speaker hasn't hit stores yet, but that hasn't stopped Samsung from working on a miniature version of the Bixby-powered device

Chevy's safety feature won't let teens drive without New! 2019-05-21 13:46:00Because a chiming dashboard alert isn't enough to get teens to buckle up, Chevrolet introduced a new feature that prohibits drivers from shifting out

How tech does (and doesn't) help babies sleep New! 2019-05-21 13:30:00The truth is, technology probably does more to interrupt a child's sleep than help induce it Both exposure to screens and addictive routines can keep

Airbnb's 'heritage travel' section is for exploring 23andMe New! 2019-05-21 13:11:0023andMe has partnered with Airbnb to let users literally explore their roots. The travel website now has a special "heritage travel" section divided

Apple says it fixed the MacBook Pro keyboard New! 2019-05-21 13:00:00The MacBook Pro is getting an upgrade today and yes, it's the upgrade you've been waiting for. After acknowledging problems with the "butterfly" m

Netflix's 'Dark Crystal' prequel series will premiere August New! 2019-05-21 12:45:00Netflix has lined up a release date for its Dark Crystal prequel series. The Dark Crystal: Age of Resistance will be available for your enjoyment via

Watch trailers for each 'Black Mirror' episode in New! 2019-05-21 12:24:00With season five of Black Mirror set to debut on June 5th, Netflix released trailers for each of the season's three episodes. They star Anthony Macki

Lyft adds in-app 911 and prominent license plates New! 2019-05-21 12:12:00Lyft is joining Uber in responding to the death of a college student with improved safety features. To begin with, it's adding an Uber-style option

WIRED

Can Baze’s Blood Test Tell You Which Vitamins 2019-05-20 08:00:00A company called Baze is offering a bespoke mail-order vitamin service that crafts a plan just for you based on the results of an at-home blood test.

Parents and Kids Weigh in on Their Family's 2019-05-20 06:00:00What's your screen time scheme?

The Quiet Power of Sound Design 2019-05-20 06:00:00Our lives are increasingly entangled with our devices; great sound design could make that a more perfect union.

Build a Raspberry Pi GoBot With Your Kids 2019-05-20 06:00:00With just $60 worth of hardware and 10 lines of code, you and your child can build a simple wheeled droid that can drive around the house.

Hearing Aids Get a Tech-Minded Upgrade 2019-05-20 06:00:00Spurred by regulations that will allow over-the-counter sales, hearing-aid companies are pushing the limits of what their products can be.

Q Acoustics' Concept 300 Speakers Kill Sound-Smearing Vibrations 2019-05-20 06:00:00Errant sound waves can keep speakers from delivering their best performance. Q Acoustics neutralizes sonic invaders in three ways.

Ingenious Audio Designs From Audeze, Bang & Olufsen, 2019-05-20 06:00:00Wireless technology is helping audio gear explore new horizons in form and functionality.

12 Best Android Phones of 2019 (New, Unlocked, 2019-05-19 08:00:00Wonder what the absolute best Android phone is right now? We have the answer, and some alternatives, including Google Pixel, OnePlus, Samsung Galaxy,

5 Best Keyboards for 2019 (Cheap, Gaming, Mechanical) 2019-05-18 08:00:00Whether you're looking to boost your productivity or your kill-death battle royale stats, these are the best keyboards for the job.

REI Anniversary Sale: 26 Best Summer Outdoor Deals 2019-05-18 07:00:00REI is holding its Anniversary Sale from now through Memorial Day. It's the best time of the year to pick up all the wetsuits, mountain bikes, and co

Gadget Lab Podcast: YouTube’s Latest Makeup Drama, Explained 2019-05-17 12:36:57WIRED’s Emma Grey Ellis joins this week’s Gadget Lab podcast to explain the latest YouTube drama and discuss the implications of “ca

Sony Alpha A7II Mirrorless Camera Deal: $600 Off 2019-05-17 08:00:00Sony's Alpha A7II is a mirrorless, full-frame workhorse of a camera, and a steal at less than $1,000.

Ars Technica » Gear

Google Glass still exists: Meet Google Glass Enterprise 2019-05-20 16:19:34It has a modern 10nm Qualcomm SoC, a bigger battery, and a version with safety glasses!

Google reportedly ends business with Huawei, will cut 2019-05-20 09:47:44Trump's Huawei ban means no early access to Android Q, no Google app ecosystem.

There’s a new Minecraft game coming, and it’s 2019-05-17 19:12:54You can build on your table, then deploy your build full-size on your street.

Creator claims Lenovo stole foldable Moto Razr video 2019-05-17 18:00:02Why would you steal a fan-made render of a phone you are supposedly working on?

OnePlus 7 Pro Review—The fastest, best-designed, best-value Android 2019-05-17 11:41:01OnePlus crushes the competition with a 90Hz display, pop-up camera, and a killer price.

Guidemaster: Ars picks the best wireless keyboards you 2019-05-17 07:40:05Ditch your default keyboard and get one of these stellar accessories.

These firms promise high-tech ransomware solutions—but typically just 2019-05-16 16:35:15Two US data recovery firms offer help. ProPublica finds they paid ransoms and charged extra.

Saved from obsolescence, Microsoft is now making Paint 2019-05-16 15:30:51Paint is getting keyboard controls to improve accessibility.

The Samsung Galaxy S10 5G is the US’ 2019-05-16 13:45:225G means a super-sized, $1,300 Galaxy S10 with less metal and more glass.

Windows dual booting no longer looking likely on 2019-05-15 18:50:11Development work appeared to grind to a halt last December.

Microsoft open sources algorithm that gives Bing some 2019-05-15 11:51:36You can ask "How tall is the tower in Paris?" and it knows what you're talking about.

New speculative execution bug leaks data from Intel 2019-05-14 14:10:55Intel-specific vulnerability was found by researchers both inside and outside the company.

TechCrunch » Gadgets

Why is Facebook doing robotics research? 2019-05-20 16:06:41It's a bit strange to hear that the world's leading social network is pursuing research in robotics rather than, say, making search useful, but Face

This clever transforming robot flies and rolls on 2019-05-20 14:15:53There's great potential in using both drones and ground-based robots for situations like disaster response, but generally these platforms either fly

Huawei responds to Android ban with service and 2019-05-20 05:28:32Huawei has finally gone on the record about a ban on its use of Android, but the company’s long-term strategy on mobile still remains unclear. I

Google says its app store will continue to 2019-05-20 02:54:15Google said today that existing users of Huawei Android devices can continue to use Google Play app store, offering some relief to tens of millions of

Rivian debuts a pull-out kitchen for its electric 2019-05-17 15:44:39Sometimes you need scrambled eggs. And with that thought, today at the Overland Expo in Flagstaff, AZ, Rivian announced a major accessory for its elec

Minecraft Earth makes the whole real world your 2019-05-17 09:01:45When your game tops a hundred million players, your thoughts naturally turn to doubling that number. That's the case with the creators, or rather ste

ObjectiveEd is building a better digital curriculum for 2019-05-16 15:03:21Children with vision impairments struggle to get a solid K-12 education for a lot of reasons — so the more tools their teachers have to impart b

Rivals in gaming, Microsoft and Sony team up 2019-05-16 14:50:18For the last two decades, Sony and Microsoft's gaming divisions have been locked in all-out war against one another: on price, on hardware, on franch

The Meizu 16s offers flagship features at a 2019-05-16 14:43:33Smartphones have gotten more expensive over the last few years even though there have only been a handful of recent innovations that really changed th

Having trouble with Amazon Alexa? You’re not the 2019-05-15 20:23:08Update: An Amazon spokesperson told TechCrunch “This afternoon we had an issue that impacted some Alexa customers’ ability to interact wit

Is the new Osmo Action camera a GoPro 2019-05-15 12:27:12I got my hands on DJI’s Osmo Action cam and took it out for a spin. Check out the video for my initial impressions. Video Producer: Gregory S. M

DJI is out-GoProing GoPro with its own action 2019-05-15 09:00:43For a brief time, DJI and GoPro were partners — or at least uncomfortable allies. Way back in 2014, the companies were joined together with the


Disclaimer and Notice:WorldProNews.com is not responsible of these news or any information published on this website.